Analyzing Searle's The Chinese Room Argument
In his article, Searle discusses two statements. The first is that intentionality in humans is caused by features of the brain, so certain processes in the brain are satisfactory for intentionality. The other statement he discusses is that a computer program can never have intentionality.
Searle states that ‘strong AI’ demands that any programmed computer displays intentionality similar to human’s. With arguments he gives, the goal is to show that this is not the case.
The argument he uses, is named The Chinese Room argument. With this argument he tries to prove that when a computer acts exactly like a human, there is still no certainty that the computer thinks like a human.
The chinese room argument
Imagine an English speaking person,
Tex G. Hall's Argument
326 Words | 2 PagesThe author Tex G. Hall is explaining Native American team sports mascots are racist. He is testifying for many other people as well. He makes a very sensible are you and uses the motion and great facts facts. The way his argument is structured is very engaging. He first off thanks many people for bringing this controversy to everyone 's attention.
Arguments In Fracknation By Phelim Mcaleer
600 Words | 3 PagesThere are two sides to every argument and hydrofracturing is no different. Phelim McAleer, an investigative journalist and producer of FrackNation, uses logic to convince viewers that fracking does not pose environmental concerns. Josh Fox however, employs a multitude of logical fallacies as well as arguments based on emotions in an attempt to convince the audience that fracturing is bad for the environment. McAleer created his film to refute this opinion. Ultimately, Phelim McAleer’s documentary made a better argument than Josh Fox’s documentary.
Blumenfeld's English Only Laws Divide And Demean
1036 Words | 5 PagesImagine being punished for saying one word or phrase in your first language that just comes natural to you. This is another example that makes the audience question their own beliefs on the “English only”
Ethos Pathos And Logos In The Blade Runner
605 Words | 3 PagesHe argues that machines can simply match an input with an output, but this does not indicate that there is any understanding (4). This can be further explained as Searle illustrates the simulation of a person being given Chinese characters to view with no knowledge whatsoever of the language. The person is given another set of Chinese writing with instructions in English that help respond to the first batch of writing and for these responses to be returned. Although the responses written by the person are synonymous to what a native Chinese speaker would deem to be correct, this does not mean the person understands Chinese, but merely the instructions in English directed the person allows them to generate viable responses. Searle continues with stating that understanding requires intentionality and machines may have calculating capacities, but may not have their own intrinsic intention that reflect mental states (11).
Summary Of Nick Riggle's 'High Five'
891 Words | 4 PagesHe mainly uses various examples to prove each of his
Analysis Of Nick Riggle's 'High Five'
892 Words | 4 PagesHe mainly uses various examples to prove each of his
Emperor Norton's Argument Essay
1214 Words | 5 Pages"Every age has its peculiar folly; some scheme, project or phantasy into which it plunges, spurred on either by the love of gain, the necessity of excitement, or the mere force of imitation. Julie Andrews, Tom Hiddleston, Taylor Swift... These are just a few select names that you 've probably heard of before. They are celebrities still alive today, that nearly everyone has heard about at least once. Some of them even have a wide fan base, with people who love them around the globe.
Thomas Chang The Playground Analysis
162 Words | 1 PagesThe Playground” has more morals than just running around and coaching some children during the summer for Thomas Chang. As he exclaims, “That summer job turned out to be one of the best learning experiences I’ve ever had.” (pg.1) Even though he was scared or not sure if he wanted to “walk onto playground,” he still took that chance and the second week was ready to venture out on his own. He realized that in order to teach someone or even just coach them you have to earn their respect. For example, he discovered that “blowing a whistle and shouting was not impressive,” (pg.1) or didn’t get them to do anything.
Summary Of John Searle's Chinese Room Argument
2029 Words | 9 PagesSupporters of computationalism and strong artificial intelligence claim that computers are capable of intelligence and other cognitive states if they are programed correctly. Therefore, computers can explain how human cognition performs. I contend that John Searle is correct in his claim that computers are incapable of understanding language and are, therefore, unable to explain human cognition. I begin the essay with Searle’s Chinese room argument, and explain how he uses it to prove that computers cannot understand language as they operate on syntax alone, where syntax is insufficient in producing understanding. Thereafter, I provide a description of the robot reply to the Chinese room argument, which states that a robot with a computer insert and sensory apparatus would be able to achieve understanding, a view which Searle argues is still insufficient.
Descartes And Paley's Argument Analysis
925 Words | 4 PagesHe further elaborates on this watch saying that even if you had never seen a watch made or known someone to make it you would still recognize that the watch had a creator. Also the watch at times may go wrong, even if this happens it still does not prove that the watch does not have a creator. Further that the watch has parts whose functions are unknown this still does not determine that the watch does not have a creator. Ultimately what this argument comes down to is that the watch is an analogy for the universe and or human beings. All of these things he attributed to the watch is in like fashion attributed to the universe.
Galen Strawson's Analysis
786 Words | 4 PagesGalen Strawson argues in his work, The Impossibility of Moral Responsibility, the theory that true moral responsibility is impossible. This theory is accurate whether determinism is true or false. Strawson describes this argument as the Basic Argument. He claims "nothing can be causa sui- nothing can be the cause of itself" (212).
To Speak Is To Blunder Analysis
1635 Words | 7 PagesYiyun Li feels that same way and can’t comprehend but feel separated from her own language’s culture. “In my relationship with English, in this relationship with the intrinsic distance between a nonnative speaker and an adopted language that makes people look askance, I feel invisible but not estranged. It is the position I believe I always want in life. But with every pursuit there is the danger of crossing a line, from invisibility to erasure” (Lin 7). This clearly shows that she can be isolated from the people around her.
Fruit Of The Lemon Analysis
1020 Words | 5 PagesFor Chin community’s children, many people came to the United States at a young age that they barely know anything about their culture. It was hard for them to live in a mix-cultures because they are comfortable with the American culture, yet they also acquire to live with their parents’ culture. However, inside of their household, their parents taught them their culture’s tradition and show them certain part of the tradition. Those lessons make kids know about their own culture and be able to understand in many ways including language barrier that they have. Thous, a few children who did not learn their native culture also bear a hard time dealing with all these native-new-cultures things.
The Pros And Cons Of The Turing Test
1042 Words | 5 PagesDefining intelligence is a very difficult proposition and one which Alan Turing attempted to avoid answering as regards machine intelligence in the Imitation Game which has become known as the Turing Test (Turing, 1950). He posed the question “Can machines think?” which is he developed to ask if machines are able to converse in a way that can persuade humans they too are human. A machine is declared to have passed the test if human judges are unable to tell the difference between a human and a computer through a typed conversation. He suggested that a machine that persuades 70 per cent of human judges after five minutes of conversation should be deemed to have passed the test.
Essay On Language Discrimination
1437 Words | 6 PagesYour organization as of late declared a "communicate in English-just" arrangement, and your manager has let you know not to ever communicate in Cantonese to your associates while at work. Second example is that if another client benefit position opens in your organization. You apply for the activity since it pays a higher pay and more customary work hours. Even though you are familiar with English, you are told by the chief that you can't be considered for the position since you talk with a Spanish articulation. Another representative who talks with a British articulation is met for the position.
More about Analyzing Searle's The Chinese Room Argument
Tex G. Hall's Argument
326 Words | 2 PagesArguments In Fracknation By Phelim Mcaleer
600 Words | 3 PagesBlumenfeld's English Only Laws Divide And Demean
1036 Words | 5 PagesEthos Pathos And Logos In The Blade Runner
605 Words | 3 PagesSummary Of Nick Riggle's 'High Five'
891 Words | 4 PagesAnalysis Of Nick Riggle's 'High Five'
892 Words | 4 PagesEmperor Norton's Argument Essay
1214 Words | 5 PagesThomas Chang The Playground Analysis
162 Words | 1 PagesSummary Of John Searle's Chinese Room Argument
2029 Words | 9 PagesDescartes And Paley's Argument Analysis
925 Words | 4 PagesGalen Strawson's Analysis
786 Words | 4 PagesTo Speak Is To Blunder Analysis
1635 Words | 7 PagesFruit Of The Lemon Analysis
1020 Words | 5 PagesThe Pros And Cons Of The Turing Test
1042 Words | 5 PagesEssay On Language Discrimination
1437 Words | 6 Pages