A hero is someone who does a meaningful deed, worthy of remembrance and selflessly. Andrew Carnegie was a wealthy man. After he sold his steel company in 1900, he devoted the rest of his life giving money to charity. Did Andrew Carnegie’s generosity make him a hero? Andrew Carnegie was not a hero. Carnegie is not a hero because he took money, only gave to other wealthy recipients, and contributed largely to his own. Andrew Carnegie took money away from deserving people. Carnegie cut the wages of his workers to donate money elsewhere. In document D, there are two images of Carnegie, one is giving a wage cut notice to the workers and the other is giving a check to Scotland and donating a library to Pittsburg. Carnegie’s employees were working hard and trying to survive in a tough economy, their wages did not deserve a cut. Andrew Carnegie could have let his employees keep their wages and worry about donations later. Taking money away to invest it somewhere else is not helping, because the people …show more content…
Carnegie was not a hero, because a hero does a deed selflessly, but he thought a lot about himself. 184,400,000 dollars was spent on big-name corporations and associations that would honor him by naming a meaningful belonging after him (Doc C). Carnegie was a man who wanted to feed his ego but should have donated money to help the community, not make himself known. Andrew Carnegie was not a true hero. Many may say, going from rags to riches makes Carnegie a hero. Going from rags to riches makes someone a role model to others, to show how life can be improved through any situation. Andrew took money from good people, he only gave to other wealthy associations, and contributed mainly to his own company. A hero performs acts to help the community, discreetly or anonymously; Andrew Carnegie did
He donated lots of money to people and places and charities that needed it the most . This would be one reason why someone would think he is heroic. Many people would not really see this heroic because he was a wealthy man he had a lot more money than what he donated. Yes he did donate a good portion of his money but people
As a philanthropist, he donated money to support education and other facilities. However, his philanthropy cannot cover up the fact that he was still a villain. That leads to the big question: Did Andrew Carnegie’s philanthropy make him a hero? In my opinion, his philanthropy did not make him a hero at all for various reasons. One of the myriad reasons of Carnegie not being a hero was because he hired
No matter who someone's hero is one thing stays the same. A hero is someone that has strived to help out of their own will. Anyone could be a hero. However not everyone is a hero. Being a hero takes courage.
Andrew Carnegie's views on wealth is almost the same as how billionaires think and use their money today . Carnegie's thought that people with money they would be able to help the poor by building libraries and other type of building that would help the middle class to get an education. He taught by helping the middle class rise from poverty and give them an education they would be able to do great things in life. Based on what I have read in both article Andrew Carnegie's views were considered ethical because he wanted what was best for the poor and he wanted to help the coal miners and give everyone an education.
A hero is someone who puts others before themselves. Heroic acts can range from small gestures to saving countless lives. Almost anyone can be a hero. Heroes are known for their outstanding achievements and bravery. Chesley Sullenberger is a hero because he is brave, selfless, and saved the lives of many people.
Andrew Carnegie: Bettering the Community Andrew Carnegie was a Scottish-American businessman who became extremely rich through the steel industry. After gaining a lot of money, he became a philanthropist who donated his money to the making of libraries in the United States. Being a rich businessman, Carnegie writes that it is important to dispose of one’s wealth in a matter that the community can benefit from it. The way in which he comes to this conclusion and rules out the two other possibilities will be further discussed.
Ben Ediger Mrs. Lanclos Language Arts 8 November 13, 2017 A Heroic Man on a Heroic Horse A hero is a “person who is admired for achievements and noble actions”, states Merriam-Webster Dictionary. For example, just as Mrs.Lanclos runs yelling and screaming through her backyard, Paul Revere rides through the streets of Boston screaming that the British are coming.
His workers worked twelve hours a day, seven days a week for barely anything, and then he tried to implement a 30% pay reduction. While he sat and did nothing, earning millions, his workers worked tirelessly for hours upon hours and barely earned enough to survive. He was a Robber Baron in the sense that he took advantage of his workers. Andrew Carnegie was a Captain of Industry. He donated $9.5 billion dollars to charities, libraries
A hero before anything cannot be selfish. Heroes don’t think about themselves their central focus us to keep others. Zaevion Dobson is a great example of a hero. Born in June 2000 his life was cut short.
A hero does things for others even if it means sacrificing their needs to get the job done. For instance, Frederick Douglass was determined to get others to turn against slavery. Douglas shares his ideas about being a former slave and an abolitionist inspiring others to join the movement (SB, 71). Therefore, Douglass was considered a hero, in the North’s eyes, because he didn’t care if people hated on him because of his ideas, he just kept persevering. In addition, Welles Crowther is also a hero because of his heroic, quick thinking actions during the 9/11 attack.
A Hero is brave when it comes to a dangerous situation. Abraham Lincoln helped ended slavery throughout the country. Ended slavery was a courageous act because he knew half of the country would hate him. Being a hero means standing up for what they believe. Martin Luther King stated that “I look to the day when people will not be judged by the color of
Hollywood defines a hero as a person who is capable of supernatural actions, such as lifting cars above their heads, flying, or shooting webs out of their wrists. This illustration gives kids the unrealistic desire to be this kind of hero, which will soon let them down when they realize people can’t fly, lift cars, or shoot webs. The dictionary’s definition of a hero is a person who is worshiped and well known for his or her outstanding achievements, also giving an inaccurate definition. A famous person who donated money to a charity or a supernatural being should not be named a hero for these actions because according to John Greenleaf Whittier, “One brave deed does not make a hero.”
How is someone a hero? The definition of a hero is a person who is admired or idealized for courage, outstanding achievements, great/brave acts, or noble qualities. Joseph Smith was a hero. He did all of the thing that are listed. Some people hated him and thought that what he did or saw wasn’t true.
Heroes are not what you think. Heroes are not men in capes waiting to save the city. instead they are normal people who risk their lives for others, are determined to reach their goals, and are not greedy but give to others. Heroes risk their lives for others. Frederick Douglas risked his life by speaking out about slavery “for if i spoke to the wrong one i would fall into the hands of money loving kidnappers.”
A historical figure Frederick Douglass one said it 's easier to build strong children then to repair broken men former slave African-American he was an inspiration for teaching himself and others who were treated unfairly in the circumstances of slavery. Bill Gates is a multi billionaire in fact if he gave all of his money to every single person in the world everyone received $11. But he didn 't use his money for that nonsense, he used it to help schools, Businesses, and charities. Being a hero doesn 't have to involve working as a marvel character, it is having a good character, your own