ipl-logo

Anne Hutchinson's Criticism Of The Puritan Society

1083 Words5 Pages

“But now having seen him which is invisible I fear not what man can do unto me” – Anne Hutchinson. Anne Hutchinson was a fearless opponent of the Puritan faith during the beginnings of America. Hutchinson was born in England but then traveled to what is now America with her family to live in the Massachusetts Bay Colony. In the Colony she got involved in the Puritan church and eventually fell into controversy within the society. Through her conflicting religious beliefs, Anne Hutchinson imposed the conservative and conventional role of women in the Puritan society. Hutchinson’s opposition of the Puritan society was derived from her criticism of the Puritan’s conforming laws and extreme views on the Bible. For instance, she disliked their …show more content…

The Puritan’s practiced religion as The Cabinet would practice politics: lawful and authoritative. The supporters that Hutchinson had in Boston proved that she was not the only one who opposed the teachings of the Puritans but she was one of the few to vocalize her opinions. In addition, Hutchinson combated the Puritan’s doctrines: “Among her beliefs that varied from the Puritan doctrines were the concepts that salvation came through their faith alone, that enslaving the Indians was wrong, and that God revealed himself directly to each believed without the need of clergy” (Adams). Anne believed one could channel God without the mediating of a minister or preacher. Also, Anne felt merciful towards the Natives because the colonists had stormed their land and conquered it without the Native’s consent. Then, …show more content…

For example: “Hutchinson publicly spoke out against the Puritan religious leaders: In an era when women were admonished to obedience, passivity, and meekness, Hutchinson defended her theological position and provided the women of the Massachusetts Bay Colony with a model of independence and resourcefulness” (Seton 156). Anne Hutchinson was unwilling to let a male authority tell her how to behave and worship. She was a beacon of hope for the other women who also felt this way but were too scared of the outcomes of vocalizing their oppositions. In addition, Hutchison was viewed as a threat due to her intellect: “Hutchinson was intelligent and persuasive, but her perceived air of superiority must have seemed to the church fathers especially inappropriate coming from a woman. Winthrop in particular had no patience for women who (as he wrote in his journal) “meddle in such things as are proper for men, whose minds are stronger” (Moore). John Winthrop was afraid of Hutchinson’s influence over the Puritan population. He was scared to have his title taken from him if Hutchinson grew more popular. More importantly, Anne Hutchinson set a pattern of separatists to come: “In daring to think differently from the colonial autocrats who would brook no disagreement, she took an early place of prominence in the development of

Show More
Related

  • What Were The Charges Brought Against Anne Hutchinson?

    254 Words  | 2 Pages

    Why did Winthrop think that the Puritans were a special people? And why did he believe they had to be especially careful in their new endeavor? Puritan wanted to reform their church and opposed to the corruption of the Church of England so they moved to the New World. John Winthrop wanted to show England that their way was wrong; therefore he wanted to prove it to them by presenting that the Puritans have a successful colony.

    Read More

  • What Role Did Anne Hutchinson Play In Early America

    96 Words  | 1 Pages

    In 1634, a woman that would play one of the biggest roles in the development of early America came to Massachusetts from England. Before immigrating to the New World though, Anne Hutchinson lived in London with her husband William Hutchinson. There, a minister, John Cotton, who believed you didn’t need to follow the laws and rules of society to connect with God, resonated greatly with Anne. The idea that religion is based on personal views would be taken with her to the New World, where she would become an icon for conservative Puritanism and steadfast determination.

    Read More

  • The Silencing Mary Luther King Jr Summary

    584 Words  | 3 Pages

    Mary Dyer had not agreed with the Puritan religion. She believed that God spoke to everyone through the urgings of his or her conscience; Puritans thought God only spoke to authorities of the church. Dyer also did not believe that the church should govern all aspects of life in the colony. At first, she kept an uneasy silence. But once a woman, Anne Hutchinson, began publically opposing the church, Dyer decided to step in as well.

    Read More

  • American Jezebel The Uncommon Life Of Anne Hutchinson

    1080 Words  | 5 Pages

    As the trial continued, Hutchinson justified her actions with scripture while Winthrop insisted on correcting her. In his mind, and in the mind of many, women were not to speak publically, should be silent in church, and should seek guidance from their husbands (LaPlante, 40). Their arguing continued until Simon Bradstreet stood up to announce his support for women’s meetings, but he also explained why Hutchinson should stop holding them. After Bradstreet spoke, others did too. Thomas Dudley then spoke up about the heart of the issue he has with Hutchinson.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Why We Can 'T Wait'

    504 Words  | 3 Pages

    In spite of the mindboggling tone that provides, indubitably it is sensible because in order to disdain an unjust law for a positive outcome suggests that the individual cares deeply about the just laws in the world. Throughout history women have typically taken a subordinate roll in life compared to men, due to patriarchal societies. Anne Hutchinson, a courageous female Puritan, challenged church authority by providing her opinions and advice about faith through her knowledge of the Bible but was taken as a threat and was thrown into the isolated area of independent thinkers, Rhode Island. Although Hutchinson experienced poor treatment after supporting her hopes and dreams she influenced many women to fight for the same cause, ultimately leading to further freedoms for the

    Read More

  • Anne Hutchinson's Struggle Against The Puritan Rule In Massachusetts

    349 Words  | 2 Pages

    About 124 years ago today, an important woman arrived at our colony, her name was Anne Hutchinson. She was one of our founders and a significant figure, not only known in this colony. Anne had a different interpretation of the Bible, this was against the Puritan rule in Massachusetts, and that’s why she was exiled to Rhode Island. While she lived in Massachusetts, Anne was recognized for holding church meetings in her own home. This was because of the way she interpreted the Bible.

    Read More

  • Strict Barriers In Puritan New England

    414 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the colonial era, women did not have many rights, and people did not consider them as equals to men, especially in Puritan New England where the Puritan beliefs governed society. Society expected women to get married, have children, and obey their husbands; they considered anything outside of these limitations as radical confrontations to the law. The woman’s main contribution to society was to teach the young girls about the customs and appropriate behaviors of a woman (Jolliffe, Roskelly, 242.45). Strict barriers existed in a woman’s life, and if a woman were to break those boundaries, like Anne Hutchinson - a revolutionary Puritan spiritual advisor - did, critics accused them of being non-compliant and harmful to society. They considered

    Read More

  • Anne Hutchinson And The Free Grace Controversy

    660 Words  | 3 Pages

    Bostonians received a new ally when the Reverend John Wheelwright arrived from England, and immediately aligned himself with Cotton, Anne Hutchinson and other "free grace" advocates. This really helped Anne Hutchinson. John Wheelwright was not only a close neighbor of Anne Hutchinson, but his wife is a sister of Anne Hutchinson’s husband. More people were beginning to follow Anne Hutchinson and her allies. When the young Henry Vane was elected as the governor of the colony, it was another boost for the free grace advocates.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Anne Bradstreet And Jonathan Edwards And The Puritans

    1079 Words  | 5 Pages

    Puritans are a people with a very strong belief in both God and the power of God. When people see power, they interpret it in different ways. Some know of power through anger and impulse, while others see power through the goodness the powerful one shows. Although Anne Bradstreet and Jonathan Edwards are both puritan poets, their writings convey mainly different, though sometimes similar, views on God because they have different perceptions of His will and the use of His power. Anne Bradstreet listens to and accepts anything that God wishes, and that is shown through her poem Upon the Burning of my House.

    Read More

  • Puritan Ideas And John Winthrop's Impact On American Culture

    1394 Words  | 6 Pages

    The ideas constructed by the Puritans were not simply a principal starting point for American culture because they were the first in the country, but because they offered distinct ways of thinking that are still deep-seated in our culture today. Although many of the ideas of Puritans have evolved or vanished over time, it is important to give credit to the Puritan writers and thinkers such as John Winthrop and John Cotton who offered ideas that were new at the time and that stayed with the American consciousness—culturally, socially, and politically. “John Winthrop's legacy can be seen primarily in the fields of government, commerce, and religion. It was religion that would most impact John's life; his religion would ultimately impact the

    Read More

  • Similarities And Differences Between Anne Bradstreet And Mary Rowlandson

    1438 Words  | 6 Pages

    During the Puritan times gender roles in the society were very anti-feminist. Women were required to act as housewives and do womanly duties such as cook, clean, and take care of their children. Women had very little freedom as far as their rights were concerned also. Puritan writers, Anne Bradstreet and Mary Rowlandson both experienced the struggle of the anti-feminist movement. From their writings we see that they both were against anti-feminism and they tried their best to abandon the whole idea.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Massachusetts And Virginia

    588 Words  | 3 Pages

    Religious freedom and toleration in the English North American colonies provided little room for those who did not practice the exact same form of government and religion. Although a similarity to America today is that the Puritan "court" provided a ruling to determine the punishment of an individual, however, the similarities stop there. When people came outright to declare their individual practices, such as Roger Williams and Anne Hutchinson, they were denounced and, in certain cases, sent into

    Read More

  • Summary Of Anne Hutchinson's American Jezebel

    1036 Words  | 5 Pages

    In her book, American Jezebel: The Uncommon Life of Anne Hutchinson, the Woman Who Defied the Puritans, Eve LaPlante explores parts of the life of Anne Hutchinson. Her intent is to tell the story of Anne Hutchinson’s life and clear her name as a woman who was accused of being a heretic in colonial America. LaPlante walks the reader through the trial Anne Hutchinson had with the leaders of her colony and gives background information throughout the book to share the story of Hutchinson’s life. LaPlante starts the story of Anne Hutchinson’s life at the beginning of her well-known trial. She tells of the occurrences in the room and compares Hutchinson’s trial to her father’s trial, which was similar in their accusation and punishment.

    Read More

  • Women In Puritan Society

    516 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Puritan society, even though men and female had access to education, a very small amount of women attended school in comparison to men. In Puritan society, men were the only ones able to instruct their families and influence in decisions making. Anne Bradstreet was one of the first poets in the New World. Bradstreet was part of a well-educated family and was able to learn several languages and literature, which provided her knowledge and inspiration to compose books and poems at a young age. Puritans believed men were superior to women.

    Read More

  • Puritan Culture In The Scarlet Letter

    920 Words  | 4 Pages

    Essentially, Puritans are expected to follow a strict set of religious and moral guidelines from which their actions and morality are derived. According to Hall’s A Reforming People, these moral expectations first introduced by the pilgrims were the driving force behind the power that the Puritan ministry had over society: “Ministers and laypeople looked first to congregations as the place where love, mutuality, and righteousness would flourish, and second to civil society. …Alongside love, mutuality, and righteousness they placed another set of values summed up in the word “equity.” Employed in a broad array of contexts, the concept of equity conveyed the colonists’ hopes for justice and fairness in their social world.”

    Read More

More about Anne Hutchinson's Criticism Of The Puritan Society

Open Document