Critical Review Military Fraud: The Myth of Automatic Virtue The short story by Steve Gillman was written on the bases of his personal beliefs on the praises military received from just by joining. He starts the essay with a short paragraph saying “It is about cultural mythology that has been created in the United States, which makes all soldiers into “heroes” (Gillman 679). The most important part of this quote was that by reading it the readers would understood that he was clearly against that all soldiers where no heroes. Gillman later supports the quote with some facts later in the essay. Although, the author gave a strong thesis the next paragraph was given with a true story headline. This headline was a persuasive way to get readers …show more content…
He used the war as a tool without even stating that he was talking about the war. But the mere fact each one of us was a part of this war against terrorist was later to be found pointless and we used killing others to try to heal the wounds and be peaceful. In fact, in the essay he wrote “young men dying for no good reason” (Gillman 680) informing the reader that that particular soldier could have only wanted to get his college tuition paid for. Because, he only wanted to get his college paid for and he was randomly killed by a stray bullet make him a …show more content…
The praises that you receive shouldn’t be based on the mere fact that you join but maybe for those who actually wants to serve and protect. In contrast, he says “Make that choice without looking back to see the cheering faces of those who tell you your duty is to do what they are not doing for purposes you may not know nor share” (Gillman 680). None the less, the author let the reader know that these young men and women risk their own lives for purposes which may not be of any value to themselves or the country. As a result, those purposes doesn’t deserve the praises that are
The military as well as the police force have continuously abused their preeminent title of being a hero. The word is so broadly defined that even a newly recruited military member, who wears the uniform, but has not yet served still qualifies as one. No matter how they treat others or represent themselves; if they wear a badge they get the praise and approval of everyone. However, David Masciotra bluntly shows the true colors of our role models. By defining hostily what doesn’t qualify and bringing up emotionally furtive secrets, he effectively demands that the carte blanche interpretation behind the word hero gets a slimmer and clearly definitive meaning.
You say to your soldier, 'Do this' and he does it. But I am obliged to say to the American, 'This is why you ought to do this' and then he does it”. This is a quote from Baron von Steuben he is basically saying that he gives them a reason of they should do this so he can understand. This is the life and events that happen during baron von steuben's life time. Baron von Steuben’s early life lead him into meeting people from America that could use his military experience for help during the revolution,then once the war was over he settled into the new country that he helped free.
The components of a “true” war story are defined through its moral and purpose. A “true” war story
The intense and epic movie, Black Hawk Down, directed by Ridley Scott, dives deep into the treacherous and blood filled mission aimed at taking down a Somalia warlord. An epic film must have in it a hero of imposing stature, a setting of vast scope, actions of great deeds or superhuman strength, supernatural forces at work, and a style of sustained elevation. Due to the imposing stature of Sergeant Eversmann, the vast setting of the Somalian village, and the valorous actions and great deeds carried all the soldiers; Black Hawk Down embodies the characteristics of an epic film.
Umar Al-Khattab once said “no amount of guilt can change the past and no amount of worrying can change the future.” The novel The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brien is based on his experience in the Vietnam war from a soldier's perspective. He expresses his emotions well thought his writing by telling both factual and made up stories. He describes his experiences from during the war and after, a beautiful mixture of friendship, love and protection but also a tragedy of loss, rejection and regret. In The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brien, the theme of regret leads to the theme of guilt, both of which are evidenced in the novel through O’Brien’s portrayal of recovering past events, memories, and storytelling.
Throughout history, countries are inevitably pulled into conflicts that result in war. These conflicts usually occur because of interests in: economic gain, territorial gain, religion, and nationalism. America, like every country, needs a military to defend itself, especially when tensions arise in other parts of the world and when militia numbers start to decrease. This then allows the government to draft its population to serve in the military. People argue that young men and women’s bright lives are often cut short, and not allowed their Constitutional right to “Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness”, but there are many benefits for the nation and the individual by serving one’s country.
Similarly “Duty, Honor, Country,” by Douglas MacArthur, the author talks about how serving in the military brings gratitude and satisfaction to the soldier when officially done with their job. MacArthur who was once a soldier explains to the young militants that “when [he thinks] of his patience under adversity, of his courage under fire, and of his modesty in victory, [he] is filled with an emotion of admiration he cannot put into words” (MacArthur
Many soldiers are not re-enlisting or are deserting before their nine-month re-enlistment has ended. General Washington, desperate to keep an army together to fight the war against Britain has asked us soldiers look into our hearts and ask ourselves the following question: Will you quit? To quit would be to not re-enlist. I have decided to not re-enlist for three reasons which are high chances of illness, horrible lodging and weather, and sparse food and clothing.
Finally war kill lots of people. One example is “I think we ought to bomb the daylights out of them, as long as we don’t hit any women or children or old people, don’t you?… ‘Or hospitals,’ he went on. ’And naturally no schools. Or churches.’ ‘We must also be careful about works of art,’...
As General, he’s experienced and knows a soldier “… mission remains fixed, determined, and inviolable: it is to win our wars.” He relates to the cadets by showing them he’s been in the same position they are in today. Due to his own personal experiences, any American soldier can prosper through the horrific ways of war because their duty and honor is to this country. Everyone needs to know that there is someone who understands and even a soldier needs to know that no matter how dark the times get that there is at least one person that will understand what goes on and happens in the hard
“Every citizen should be a soldier. This was the case with the Greeks and Romans, and must be that of every free state”, said Thomas Jefferson. Since the beginning of history, men have been drafted into the wars whether it be by force or simply choosing to fight for their country. Millions upon trillions of families have had their families cruelly torn apart from the loss of military men. There are multiple military forces in which you have to pledge to confirm your loyalty to our country to even be involved.
I feel a debt of gratitude to America, and no better way to repay than through military service. I’ve observed that a key objective for the military is the intent to inspire. With an extensive background in family Naval history, my grandfather (Navy 0-5 F6F Hellcat pilot), uncle (Navy 0-5 F-14 pilot), mother (Navy 0-4 Intelligence Officer), and father (Navy 0-4 C-2 Greyhound pilot) have all influenced me to follow the tradition generations old. The aspiration to secure our skies and seas exhilarates me to no end. I want to provide the chance of a valuable and productive life to future posterity, attributes that have been afforded to me.
Passos says this but never really writes about the “ joy of freedom “ in the army. “ People don’t choose their career, they are engulfed by them” (Passos). Many of the men in the army did not choose to be there, they were drafted.
Throughout my childhood and adolescent years, I always had a dream of joining the military. Though it was a choice, I still did not have any inside information of what it would be like, and the requirements and specifics of the Army. It wasn't until 2005 when I decided to join the United States Army that all my concerns and questions were answered by a recruit; and I was guided through the whole process to enter and prep for the Army. If it was not for the confidences and motivation of my recruiter back in 2005, I might have not made my leap and probably would not be in this uniform today. Becoming a member of the United States Army recruiting team means having a physical and mental toughness in order to perform efficiently.
The message is clear: if you enlist in the army, you will be a noble man, a hero. In this case the government alters information by changing what war looks like. In reality participating in war is often traumatic and not all soldiers get to use modern equipment like motorcycles. This change is made so that citizens enroll in war. They don’t know what they’re signing up for.