A good leader should respect the people they’re working with, take ownership of their mistakes, and be trustworthy. Odysseus didn’t show most of these traits, Odysseus didn’t care about his crew as much as he should have. Percy Jackson showed great respect to his crew, he was close friends with the people he was working with which made it easier for them to get along and complete tasks together. Odysseus’ men betrayed him when they opened the bag of wind that blew them back home, if Odysseus had a good relationship with his crewmates, that wouldn’t have happened. Odysseus shouldn’t have treated his men the way that he did, Percy Jackson is a better leader than Odysseus in many ways.
Odysseus didn’t have enough respect for his crew. Odysseus’ men were taking him across the ocean so that he could get home and weren’t getting compensated for it. Odysseus showed bad leadership when he left his men alone so he could sleep and while he was sleeping they opened a bag of wind and they were blown in the opposite direction of where they were headed. Odysseus showed very little care when six of his men were killed by Scylla, he almost ignored it and just continued his
…show more content…
It’s important to be somewhat familiar with people that you will be doing life-threatening tasks with, it makes it easier when you can work as a team rather than one person doing the work by themselves. When Percy was in the boat with his friends, they worked together to get where they needed to be instead of him not doing any of the work because of “superiority”. Everyone in the group helped each other out, if someone was injured they would take the time to help them, or if someone was in a life-threatening situation they wouldn’t have to fend for themselves. Percy showed affection and care towards his crew, they would all look out for each other emotionally as well as physically, and they felt comfortable enough to put themselves in a vulnerable
He arrives at multiple places along the journey, some more dangerous than others. In Homer’s epic poem The Odyssey, Odysseus is an ineffective leader and shows how risky qualities and carelessness of an individual can lead to disastrous consequences for a group. Odysseus is a poor leader because he shows risky qualities while with his crew at the cyclops. At
In all, I think that Odysseus did a wonderful job being a leader, while he did have some faults along the way there
Percy Jackson was a better leader than Odysseus. Percy was loyal and he did leave any of his people behind. Percy Jackson from Percy Jackson The Sea of Monsters and Odysseus from The Odyssey. Percy Jackson is better than Odysseus as a leader.
Percy Jackson was the better hero than Odysseus. Percy Jackson was a great leader and he meets the qualifications needed to be a better hero. Qualities that a hero should possess in order to be a leader are quick- thinking, caring for others, and trusting the right people. Percy Jackson is the better hero because he is a quick thinker. When Percy and his friends were swallowed up by Charybdis Percy instantly decided they needed to find a way out fast.
Odysseus is a bad leader since he is a murderer. When Odysseus and his men landed in Ismarus, “[He] stormed that place and killed the men who fought(Homer 28). Because of this, we can see Odysseus kills people for fun, which is a very bad quality. As well, Odysseus is greedy and does things even if they could put him and his men in danger. After successfully escaping, Odysseus taunts the Cyclops, “O Cyclops!
Odysseus’s reckless decisions in this instance, threaten his crew and indicate that he is an unqualified leader. Furthermore, near the
Percy Jackson and Odysseus are both amazing characters who went through great adventures, but which one is the real hero? A hero isn’t just about being kind or saving the world, but rather giving 110% and risking everything for others. A hero needs to use their strengths and talents to be courageous through hardships and struggles they may face. Odysseus was smart, brave, and strong, but he used those qualities selfishly.
Dwight Eisenhower once said, "The supreme quality of leadership is integrity." Odysseus displayed a lack of integrity and poor leadership by not fully communicating all the facts of the situation
Ultimately Odysseus can be a good leader but behind the scenes, he's not. He may of saved his men multiple times, but also got them killed them due to his neglect. He might be intelligent but really he tolerably manipulated his crew by saying things such as “don’t you want to go back to your home again?”. In closing, throughout the whole story, Odysseus progresses himself and designates many Greek
In the novel The Odyssey, written by Homer, Odysseus is portrayed as a bad leader because of his selfish decisions and bad character. Odysseus makes a selfish decision when he leads his crew to stay in Polyphemus’s cave thinking he would offer gifts and Odysseus would “accept (his) help, or any gifts/” he had to “give” (9.726-727). This is a selfish act because he is putting his crew in danger for something that would only benefit himself. In the end, many of his people died and no one benefited. Once again, Odysseus displayed selfish acts when Circe told him “ he will be the only survivor of their long journey” (Homer 764).
Leaders come in all shapes and sizes, however, what gives someone the title of a good or bad is decided by the decisions they make and how those decisions affect others. Odysseus led the squadron of soldiers in the trojan horse and is a hero of the Trojan War and the king of Ithaca. Consequently, this gives him experience when it comes acting in difficult situations. This experience should guide him to choose correctly when being put in a tight spot.
Odysseus shouldn't even be referred to as a leader. Percy Jackson is brave and will fight for what he wants. When Percy was stopping the monster he put everything on the line. Percy was willing for his life to end so others could keep living. This falls into being a protective leader.
Percy Jackson versus Odysseus: who was the better leader? Within their own stories, the Odyssey and Percy Jackson: sea of monsters. Good Traits a good leader needs to have to lead a team are Leaders need to be clever, smart, and heroic. Each of these traits will help lead the crew and get them out of bad situations and be able for them to listen to and trust the leader. Percy Jackson and Odysseus both played leadership roles in their different stories, with Percy leading his friends and Odysseus leading his crew.
I didn't think leadership was something I needed to work hard at. I had already arrived”(Modglin 1). If Odysseus had just treated his crew with more respect and worked harder to be selfless he would’ve been the perfect leader, and his crew would have the utmost respect for him as a
At various times throughout the story, mainly through the trials, Odysseus made many decisions and forced his crew to go through many potentially lethal situations without preparing his own crew, or situations that were just a waste of time. This then leads to not only all of his crew being killed but the creation of many bad relationships. The first example of Odysseus mistreating his crew is when he and his crew went through the trails, “No more. Come, / let me tell you about the voyage fraught with hardship / Zeus inflicted on me, homeward bound from Troy...” 9.42-44.