Copyright Lawsuit: Kidd Williams Vs. Donald Glover
n 2018, a copyright lawsuit was filed against Donald Glover, also known as Childish Gambino, and his team for allegedly copying the hit song "This Is America" from a track titled "Made in America" by rapper Kidd Wes. The case raised questions about the extent of protection for original works of art, the importance of attribution, and the value of fair use.
The controversy began when Kidd Wes accused Donald Glover and his collaborators of stealing the melody, rhythm, and lyrics of "Made in America" for their Grammy-winning single "This Is America." According to the lawsuit, both songs share significant similarities in terms of the structure, flow, and content of the chorus, verses, and ad-libs. Kidd Wes claimed that he had uploaded "Made in America" to multiple streaming platforms in 2016 and had gained some traction before being overshadowed by "This Is America" in 2018.
The case was a high-profile example of a common issue in the music industry: the alleged copying of original songs by established artists from emerging talents. It also shed light on the legal complexities of proving copyright infringement, as well as the potential consequences for both parties involved. In this case, Kidd Wes sought damages for lost profits, royalties, and reputation, while Donald Glover and his team argued that they had not copied any protected elements
…show more content…
The court also had to consider the concept of fair use, which allows the use of copyrighted material for purposes such as criticism, commentary, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research. However, fair use is a subjective and context-dependent doctrine that requires a case-by-case evaluation of several factors, such as the purpose, nature, amount, and effect of the use on the original
Summary Of The Supreme Court Case Of VIP Products LLC
1709 Words | 7 PagesThis case was granted by the Supreme Court on Nov 21, 2022 and involves the petitioner, Jack Daniel's Properties, suing the respondent, VIP Products LLC, regarding trademark infringement. The facts of the case involves VIP Products LLC, a manufacturer of dog toys, recreating a Jack Daniel's bottle of whiskey as a dog toy called “Bad Spaniels”. The toy also contains many jokes referencing the original bottle that are of a scatalogical nature (“Jack Daniel's Properties v. VIP Products LLC”). Jack Daniel's Properties alleges that VIP Products LLC is in violation of its trademark, and the district court found that VIP Products LLC was infringing trademark, finding dilution by tarnishment (Lawson). The United States Court of Appeals for the 9th
Donald Sterling Case
618 Words | 3 PagesDonald Sterling was one of the owners the owner of the Los Angeles Clippers from 1981 to 2014, but the owner ship of the Los Angeles Clippers was taken from him after a conversation where he repeatedly used racist remarks was leaked to the media. Because of these racist remarks Donald Sterling is infamously know as one of the worst bosses in the sports industry. In the case of Donald Sterling and most bad bosses the power over which he held over the employees was crippling and created a hostile work environment. The members of the Los Angeles Clippers are signed to the team under a contract.
Burstyn V. Wilson: Article Analysis
97 Words | 1 PagesSupreme Court, in Burstyn v. Wilson, declared that the right of Americans to communicate, and receive ideas must be given and the states and cities were given fair warning that the era of total state interest was over. The majority of the Court did not follow Justice Frankfurter and simply declare the New York law void for vagueness. Instead they declared that movies were entitled to free speech protection. And even though this might not mean the application of the identical rules that govern other media of communication, it meant some protection, yet to be defined
Jimmy Page's Life And Accomplishments
714 Words | 3 PagesAlthough some suits have been won against Jimmy, he has won many due to the originality that he adds to the song. People say that on the songs that he lost is court, his songs only had minute differences. Although slight he made his music with those differences to improvise other music to make it better. Some songs Jimmy has plagiarized and lost in court are: Dazed and Confused, Bring it on Home, and Babe
Pickering V. Board Of Education Case Study
60 Words | 1 PagesOne example of freedom of expression being contested in a court of law was the Pickering v. Board of Education case Where the U.S. Supreme Court held that in the absence of proof of the teacher knowingly or recklessly making false statements, the teacher had a right to speak on issues of public importance without being terminated from his position.
Analysis Of Born In The Usa By Yusef Komunyakaa
554 Words | 3 PagesCole Davis Professor Anderson English 201 2 April 2023 Poetry Draft Poetry and music are effective mediums for spreading social and political agendas. The songs "Born in the USA" by Bruce Springsteen and "Facing It" by Yusef Komunyakaa are two examples of works that utilize poetry and music to examine the experiences and challenges of veterans. Although "Born in the USA" and "Facing It" had distinct goals when they were made, they both deal with the effects of war on people and society. Both "Born in the USA" and "Facing It" discuss the loneliness and disillusion experienced by returning troops. It's common to mistake the words of "Born in the USA," "Born in the USA, I was born in the USA," for a patriotic anthem when, in fact, they are a criticism of veterans' mistreatment and the government's inability to assist them.
Black America Again Rhetorical Devices
2540 Words | 11 PagesCommon's 2016 song "Black America Again" featuring Stevie Wonder is an example of a song made in support of racial equality. It draws attention to the challenges Black people face in the pursuit of justice, including racial wage inequality, gentrification, voting suppression, and mass imprisonment.. Common uses rhetorical devices to persuade listeners to envision the Black American story he hopes to rewrite. Common's song "America Black Again" was released at a time of tensions and the Black Lives Matter movement. Common convinces his listeners of the Black America he has seen through rhetorical strategies including ethos, pathos, and logos.
First Amendment Restrictions
351 Words | 2 PagesTime, place, and manner are “considerations that could act as restrictions on what would ordinarily be First Amendment-protected expression. Such restrictions do not target speech based on content, and in order to stand up in court, they must be applied
How Did Faden Break Copyright
522 Words | 3 PagesEven though Faden didn 't ask he still gave them credit at the end of the video and at the beginning because he put their intro that they use for movies. He should win because one he is still a school kid and he looked up disney’s rules about their movies. His work fell under fair use because his intent was not to make money but to educate. It wasn’t copyright because he was only using it for a class he wasn’t going out in public trying to sell a bunch of copies of the video. If he was doing that it would be copyright and disney would be able to sue him, but because he didn’t do that and it was only for education disney cannot sue Eric.
First Amendment Limitations
1055 Words | 5 PagesIn a democracy, freedom of speech and the press must be accorded great respect, but other values such as national security, the protection of reputation or public safety sometimes conflict with First Amendment guarantees. Discuss the approaches that have been used by the Supreme Court to define the limits on expression. How have these approaches been applied in specific cases? Several restrictions have been formulated on expression.
How Could Cartwright Successfully Judge Barnes For Slander
601 Words | 3 PagesSecond, Judge Barnes was not the one discussing the case in the hallway it was Mack Jones the assistant. Mack Jones being the assistant, discussing or telling another person that Cartwright was in fact a liar about not steeling the stereo would be the one to be sued, however that would be hard because Cartwright would have to prove that the statement is false and this was an intent harm. Both would be hard to prove.
Censorship In Fahrenheit 451, By Ray Bradbury
571 Words | 3 PagesConstitution protects speech, publications, or expression of any kind. Generally, however, the First Amendment is interpreted to mean that Congress can only limit speech when the need for a particular restriction is extremely compelling or when there is a type of speech (such as pornography or certain threats of imminent violence) that infringes on another right or freedom. When speech is restricted by the government, a “narrowly tailored” law must be passed to address just the specific need identified. Thus, under certain circumstances, speech in its many forms is subject to regulation. In determining what degree is permissible, the courts balance the interests of the state with the interests of some greater public good.
Walt Disney Studios Vs Faden Analysis
615 Words | 3 PagesThis remix also does not substitute for the original Disney Works in any conceivable market, which means it is not market harm as well. The supporting material found to show fair use in this because the Disney studios claim that they have more cups shown and that is copyrighted, but the copyrighted rules say that the
Summary Of The Song 'La Di Da Di'
986 Words | 4 PagesAfter much denial and a court case, Vanilla Ice finally backed down and agreed to pay David Bowie and the members of Queen royalties because they did, in a sense, contributed to the track. After the legal battle with Bowie and Queen, Vanilla Ice starting losing his
The Pros And Cons Of Censorship And The Social Media
1686 Words | 7 PagesCensorship can be described as the act of cutting out certain material that can be considered obscene or inconvenient for the community. This material can be found in social media such as in the TV, radio, or the internet. Censorship can be challenged because of the first amendment: freedom of speech. Free expression is the right of expressing opinions and ideas without any fear of being restrained or censored. However, freedom of speech does not include the right to incite actions that would harm others or the distribution of obscene material (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, 2000).
More about Copyright Lawsuit: Kidd Williams Vs. Donald Glover
Summary Of The Supreme Court Case Of VIP Products LLC
1709 Words | 7 PagesDonald Sterling Case
618 Words | 3 PagesBurstyn V. Wilson: Article Analysis
97 Words | 1 PagesJimmy Page's Life And Accomplishments
714 Words | 3 PagesPickering V. Board Of Education Case Study
60 Words | 1 PagesAnalysis Of Born In The Usa By Yusef Komunyakaa
554 Words | 3 PagesBlack America Again Rhetorical Devices
2540 Words | 11 PagesFirst Amendment Restrictions
351 Words | 2 PagesHow Did Faden Break Copyright
522 Words | 3 PagesFirst Amendment Limitations
1055 Words | 5 PagesHow Could Cartwright Successfully Judge Barnes For Slander
601 Words | 3 PagesCensorship In Fahrenheit 451, By Ray Bradbury
571 Words | 3 PagesWalt Disney Studios Vs Faden Analysis
615 Words | 3 PagesSummary Of The Song 'La Di Da Di'
986 Words | 4 PagesThe Pros And Cons Of Censorship And The Social Media
1686 Words | 7 Pages