Seth Berman
Ms. Roitz
Pre-IB LA 9
12/4/15
Democracy and Lobbying
America: the land of democracy. We are a nation founded by the people and for the people. Our government is supposed to represent the views of the average citizen, not some rich king in a far-off land. But currently, our government does not represent the views of the electorate. Instead, it is controlled by big corporations. How? Through the destructive force known as lobbying.
According to the Senate of the United States, lobbying is “Trying to persuade legislators to propose, pass, or defeat legislation or to change existing laws” (Lobbying, Senate.gov). A lobbyist is hired by a business or organization and tries to get a legislator to vote a certain way, either through
…show more content…
Democracy is defined as “A government in which the supreme power is vested in the people...” (Definition of Democracy, Merriam-Webster.com). Lobbying takes this power, and puts it into the hands of the corporation with the most money. Of course, the idea of lobbying isn’t terrible. It allows legislators to be informed about topics they otherwise wouldn’t have known about, (Dave Roos, HowStuffWorks.com) and it has the potential to give minorities more of a voice by allowing them to directly talk to their legislators. The right to petition the government is also in the Constitution, so lobbying, in some form, is one of our rights as Americans. But currently, lobbying does none of this. It allows rich corporations to get their way, even if it is against the interests of the nation.
So, how do we fix this? One way is to introduce heavy restrictions, ones that make the definition of a lobbyist more broad along with laws that restrict the amount of money a lobbyist can spend and how they can use it. We could also limit the amount of lobbyists any one business, organization, or individual could have. Laws like these would help lower the power single companies and organizations have in the government, while still allowing people to have a voice in their
…show more content…
Government. Billions of dollars are spent on lobbying each year in order to change laws that a single company doesn’t like, even when the rest of America does. The way lobbying works today is corrupt; it is the slayer of democracy. As a nation, we need to work together to bring the power back to the people.
Bibliography:
"Lobbying Database." OpenSecrets. CFC, n.d. Web. 9 Dec. 2015. .
"List of countries by GDP (nominal)." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 16 Nov. 2015. Web. 9 Dec. 2015.
"Lobbying." United States Senate. United States Senate, n.d. Web. 9 Dec. 2015.
Dave Roos. "How Lobbying Works." HowStuffWorks. HowStuffWorks, n.d. Web. 9 Dec. 2015.
"Legislator Gift Restrictions Overview." NCSL. National Conference of State Legislatures, 1 Oct. 2015. Web. 9 Dec. 2015.
Definition of Democracy. Merriam-Webster Beta. Merriam-Webster, n.d. Web. 9 Dec. 2015.
Spolar, Christine, and Joe Eaton. "The Food Lobby 's War on a Soda Tax." The Center for Public Integrity. Center for Public Integrity, 4 Nov. 2009. Web. 9 Dec. 2015.
"Economic Costs." Harvard T.H. Chan. The President and Fellows of Harvard College, n.d. Web. 9 Dec. 2015.
In the article “Learning to Love our Lobbyist Friends”, Frederick Allen argues that lobbyists are an imperfect necessity to democracy. Allen argues that Americans adore the lobbyists who represent them, yet despise the ones who represent causes they oppose. Allen examines the history of lobbying, and how their transparency has changed over time. Lobbying has changed from a shady and secretive system composed of bribery and scandal to a much more open and heavily regulated system whose lobbyists are well-educated and dedicated to their causes. Although scandals and cases of bribery still do occur now, various pieces of legislation have been passed over the past century to make lobbying more transparent, with registration for a lobbyist being
Representatives are elected from the United States citizenry to represent the people in Congress. Congressmen have to balance three things, national affairs, constituency matters, and party interests. Congress is influenced by money for campaigning, however normally this money comes from organizations and PAC's, for example the AARP. However the money does not come in the form of a bribe, with the AARP, instead they send out a questionnaire to candidates, and if they feel the candidate represents their interests, they will give them money for their campaign. PAC's are formed to combat individual donors and big businesses; they are essentially a pool of money, which represents certain interests.
Lobbyists speak with Congressmen and women directly, some go as far as testifying at congressional hearings. They have access only to the lower levels of the executive branch,
According to my understanding the interest groups have a lot of positive impacts, but they also come with several downfalls and several serious issues. One positive impact that the interest group have is, “it allows for better representation of interest (Green Garage, n.d.)”. Meaning the interest groups serve as a political
I have heard of a lobbyist before but never fully understood what it meant or what they do. A lobbyist is a person who tries to influence legislation on behalf of a special interest. Jack Abramoff scandal was an extreme example of influence and corruption in the United States government. It stated in the video that Abramoff "symbolizes how money corrupts Washington. " This is important because it shows how congressmen don't think they are being bought or influenced.
Many officeholders, legislators, and members of Academia argue that the supreme court decision Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission has single-handedly destroyed American democracy as we know it. This case is one of many that, in essence, allows legalized bribery to occur within the American political system, with most large money contributions to politicians coming from sizably influential corporations. Although many elected officials believe corporate money in politics strengthens democracy, it contrarily damages democracy and is the reason campaign finance reform is the greatest issue facing American politics. Since 1976, the US Supreme Court has ruled in favor of cases like Buckley v. Valeo and First National Bank of Boston v. Bellotti, which claims corporations are considered people; and based on First Amendment rights, people are allowed to spend their money within the political arena. Citizens United v. FEC is the supreme court decision that has led to further corruption within the American campaign finance system, while halting efforts to minimize money in politics.
Congress’s processes for reviewing and debating proposed legislation may be streamlined because, with the executive branch, the constituents, and the interest groups, it can help the process run smoothly. It should be streamlined because the executive branch aims at improving the function of the departments or agencies that Congress already has created as the constituents make telephone calls, respond to public opinion polls, and send faxes to keep in reach with their elected officials. Individuals and groups seek to influence members of Congress and legislation through lobbying, which they have to be well informed, knowledgeable, organized, and cooperative in order to convey others. The values that are served by streamlining is it helps to
Interest groups in Texas are relatively powerful actors in the political process. Organized interest groups and their representatives, also known as “the lobby” participates in the policymaking and political processes in Texas. Interest groups provide critical channels for Texans to communicate their political preferences and attempt to influence government actors and their fellow
The effect of Lobbyist in a democratic society is substantial, in both their economic and political power to sway votes in their favor. Throughout the history of Texas government these entities, both corporations, and people have seen their influential muscle flexed throughout the city of Austin. Examining how and why these groups exist, as well as in what manner they go about making money and contributing money to causes that they deem important. Gives a good insight into what exactly makes this world so appealing to all involved. After taking a look at the way, these lobbyists come to survive and thrive.
Ferarri Landau Mrs. Eaton Civics 7 February, 2017 Politics and Special Interest Groups Have you ever heard of special interest groups, lobbyists, or political action committees? Special interest groups are groups of people or organizations that seek or receive special advantages, typically through political lobbying. Similarly, Lobbyists seek to influence (a politician or public official) on a particular issue. Furthermore, political action committees are organizations that raise money privately to influence elections or legislation, especially at the federal level.
Policymakers are fully aware that they will face this lobbying when developing policies and have come to expect that interest groups will attempt to influence the decision making. These interest groups work hard to ensure that policies enacted reflect their preferences (Longest, 2010, p. 119-120). Legislators will seek out interest groups that support their views in order to gain more power during the
Campaign finance reform has been a hot button issue these past few decades in the United States. What makes it different from other issues? James L. Buckley says that “What distinguishes the campaign finance issue from just about every other one being debated these days is that the two sides do not divide along conventional liberal/ conservative lines.” In the Supreme Court case, Citizens United v. FEC, campaign finance reform lessened slightly.
Special interest groups are a great way for individuals to have their voice heard for specific policies they would like passed. The collective speaks louder than the individual. However, money does play too crucial a role in enabling certain groups to have more say than others. Those with money can lobby longer and more effectively which allows them to over represent the general population. This is still balanced by the fact that being an effective special interest group takes a lot of effort and money.
For an example, if there is a community that has a plant near their neighborhood and they are polluting their water supply. Homeowners will notice that their water supply are polluted with the plant’s chemical. They will most likely take this up with their elected officials. Then congress gets an issue that a plant is polluting into a water supply and the people would like this business to fix this problem. Now congress has to decide if they should or should not regulate
Democracy is a system of government in which the power to govern is vested on the citizens. This power is exercised either directly wherein citizens reach a consensus to implement policies, or indirectly through the election of representatives who will act on behalf of the citizen's interest (Janda, Berry, Goldman, and Hula, 2012). In such states that have adapted democratic government, political participation is the hallmark of citizens' right and ability to exercise their power. The definition of political participation, as with all concepts of social sciences, is subject to debate since most social science concepts are subject to the changing norms of society and government. Thus, this paper defines political participation as a social phenomenon that takes on different forms which is used by citizens to influence government policies and politics.