Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson are two notable figures in American History. Both are considered Founding Fathers and both signed the Declaration of Independence, one of the most importantly documents in the history of America. They both fully agreed with what the Declaration had to say. Another important document was the Constitution. Unlike with the Declaration of Independence though, Jefferson and Hamilton had very different views about the Constitution. Alexander Hamilton was a Federalist which means that he supported the Constitution and what it had to say. He believed that the new America needed a strong, central government and a lot of order and less liberty to keep people from following their vicious passions. The strong central government would be having a president, and one bicameral legislature for the whole country. He did not trust that the people will do the right thing if they are given a ton of liberty. He said, “Take mankind as they are and what are they governed by? Their passions,” which Hamilton states his first quote are vicious. On the other hand, Thomas Jefferson thought differently. He is an Antifederalist which means that he opposed the way that the Constitution was written. He only opposed parts of the Constitution though. He opposed the idea of a lot of the power being in …show more content…
America needs a strong, central government to function. Also, people are more drawn to what is wrong and pleases them than what is right and a central government is more able to control that. A central government could say that robbing is illegal for the whole country but, if America had separate state governments, each state would have to pass it one by one. That would make tons of criminals come to a state that did not pass that law yet. Order is also another super important thing that Alexander Hamilton talked about. You need order so people do not go astray and feel that they can do whatever they
CPUSH Transcript: Plan for the National Government Debate Between Federalist and Anti-Federalist—Hamilton vs. Jefferson Alexis Orellana FRANKLIN: Alexander Hamilton as a federalist representative, please explain in a brief summary on why a national government would be more essential opposed to an anti-federalist's view on having a state government. HAMILTON: As a supporter of the constitution we insist on the constitutions balance of power between national and state. We believe that the division of powers and having the system of checks and balances would protect citizens rights from the oppressive rule from an organized power.
Although the two Founding Fathers were both similar in a majority of their thoughts, the tiny differences between the two highlight a larger part of the nation’s history. Hamilton believed
When it comes to Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton one of the first things that comes to mind is there different views for what America should be like. They were both apart of different political parties known as the Federalist and the Democratic-Republican party which ultimately led them to wanting different things for America. As the two became rivals it was no surprise that this would go down as one of the greatest event in Americas history. Which would ultimately end up shaping what America is today and continue doing so every day.
They both contributed to the bringing up of today’s nation. However, they had different opinions and different ideas. Hamilton was way more involved in the structuring of the constitution and settling up the government than Jefferson. Even though he supported a strong executive, he understood the value of the balance of power. It should be taken into consideration that Jefferson was a slave holder and promoted that freed slaves should leave the country because they wouldn’t fit into our society.
Alexander Hamilton (2004), written by Ron Chernow delineates America's most disputable Founding Father. The book gives a wide perspective on early America, with top to bottom accentuation on Hamilton's whole life, achievements and his relationship to certain Founders. Prior to reading this book, I considered Hamilton to be an amazing yet oppressive man who was much of the time involved in conflicts with other Founders. I recall that he advocated a stronger central government, protectionism, mercantilism, and a national bank. Additionally, I knew that he composed parts of the Constitution and wrote the vast majority of The Federalist Papers.
Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton were two of President Washington’s closest advisors and they had exceedingly contrasting views on which direction this nation should go. A few of the things Jefferson and Hamilton had differing views on included the central government, the U.S. economy, and the national bank. In fact, these two people and their different factions helped to lead to the dual party system of America. The faction that Hamilton led was called the Federalists, while Jefferson led the Democratic Republicans.
Hamilton, representing the “republicans”, and Jefferson representing the “Democrats”, each had plans of action that would only benefit them, but also benefits the people they represent. One of these ideas of government is their thoughts on how to govern state and federal powers. The Constitution gives rights to the people that need to be interpreted so civilians of the U.S. don’t follow them incorrectly. One of these issues that needed interpretation was the delegation of powers between the states and the federal governments. Hamilton felt that a strong central federal government was necessary, due to his past work as treasurer.
Alexander Hamilton was a founding father of the United States, chief staff aide to George Washington, and one of the most influential interpreters of the U.S. Constitution. After the American Revolution, Hamilton believed it was necessary to eradicate the debt we owed, and to establish a nationally flowing currency to continue taking in revenue. Thomas Jefferson also believed the national debt should be eliminated. Jefferson, like Hamilton, was a founding father. He also wrote The Declaration of Independence, and was the third president of the United States.
He was able to combine an idea and politics. Hamilton is the reason the two are so closely tied together, and in doing this, he is known as the man who made modern America. He also envisioned America to have large debts, military force, and a modern economy with the large government. This is why Hamilton is probably the only who would understand America today. These are just some of the examples that Wood gives throughout the book that entail the difference in the Founders and todays
Political parties, Democratic Republicans and Federalists, started in the U.S. because of differing views of Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson, and the influence of newspapers. Jefferson’s and Hamilton’s different ways of thinking(mostly on issues that was beneficial for the country) played a huge part in the start of political parties. They fought about economy. Jefferson liked farming while Hamilton preferred manufacturing and trade. Interpretation of the Constitution was another thing they fought upon.
Both men have made very significant accomplishments during their lifetime. Jefferson became the Vice President of the United States. This position caused problems because the Executive, Legislative, and Judicial branches were in favor of the Democratic party and Jefferson was in favor of the Republican party. Therefore, it was difficult for Jefferson to obtain support because everyone disagreed with his views and ideas. If Jefferson and Hamilton did not disagree, the United States could run more
Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson were both right “in light of subsequent history”, although, in my opinion one was more right than the other. Some cases of Alexander Hamilton being correct in his educated assumptions include “a… body can check the imprudence of democracy. Their turbulent and controlling dispositions requires check.”, and how I interpreted the quote was that Hamilton’s meaning was checks and balances in the national government is necessary to “pursue the public good”. Another case presented by Hamilton that I found was, “One great error is that we supposed mankind more honest than they are. Our prevailing passions are ambition and interest: and it will be the duty of a wise government to avail itself of those passions,
Alexander Hamilton “and to two collaborators, James Madison, the delegate from Virginia, and John Jay, the secretary of foreign affairs, to write The Federalist, a series of 85 essays in defense of the Constitution and republican government” when Hamiltion was put under the heaviest pressure he could make the impossible possible. 2. Alexander Hamilton was a man of brilliance, from source Gale Encyclopedia of U.S. Economic History “Hamilton's last years were spent in the midst of political turmoil. Through various political intrigues he managed to sow dissension in his own Federalist party and to incur the enmity of several important political leaders in both the Federalist and Republican parties” As shown Hamilton could handle most problems where others would fail From source Ann, McGill, Sarah. Alexander Hamilton “studied law and was admitted to practice in July 1782.
When it comes to Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton the main difference between the two was their political party. The basis of each of their political parties set the boundaries for their beliefs and their views as politicians. Both men were founding fathers of our country, and made a huge impact on history as we know it. Without these men, our country's government might not be what it is today. One of the only similarities of Jefferson and Hamilton was their want to diminish national debt.
Hamilton vs. Jefferson Visions to Reality Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton both had very defined visions of the scope and power of the new federal government, how they saw the future of the economic development, and what the United States society should become. In my opinion Alexander Hamilton had more of an impact on the United States during the 1820’s and on contemporary government when compared to Thomas Jefferson. His policies did not strictly work during that time and many of his ideas are still seen in today’s society. Jefferson’s views and ideas on/of the national bank, higher tariffs, debt assumption, The Federalist Party, and his support of the ratification of the Constitution are all reasons in why his policies and visions came closer to becoming a reality. Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton, molded the gatherings that provoked to the twofold party system under which the U.S. works today.