Awful Parenting in Speak Melinda’s parents are guilty of neglect and horrible parenting. To start off, Melinda’s parents do not think about Melinda and are egotistical. On several events, her parents show selfishness when Melinda needed them the most. For example, when Melinda was late for school she tried asking her mom to drop her off. However, the mom said “‘You expect me to drive again.’ Another nod. ‘You will need boots it’s a long walk and it snowed again last night. I’m already late” (96). Furthermore, without understanding Melinda, her child’s situation, she made Melinda go to school, already late because she was late for work. In fact, Melinda’s mom is a manager and it would have been fine to go to work a bit late to drop her daughter off. …show more content…
As they were talking about a solution, Melinda stayed quiet. Noticing this, her mom said “‘She’s jerking us around to get attention.’ Immediately, Melinda thought, “[Inside my head] would you listen? Would you believe? Fat chance” (114). In addition, Melinda’s parents think that Melinda is being purposefully difficult to be dealt with and is asking for attention in an immature way. Moreover, they jump to conclusions and assume this as they do no think that something happened to Melinda to make her need extra attention. By being impatient and clueless to their child, they are guilty of poor parenting. As a matter of fact, the parents do not notice how Melinda feels internally. They are bewildered as to what happened to their child and even when they should be able to tell something is wrong by looking at Melinda’s wrist, they do not have an impact on helping Melinda’s situation about why she has changed. To emphasize, when the mom sees Melinda’s cut on her wrist the next morning, she says “I do not have time for this Melinda” (88). After knowing that Melinda tried committing suicide, Melinda’s parents still do not do anything to physically or mentally help her out effectively as to why she
While the kids were young, they did not really know any better so they never actually tried to talk to their parents about those things. As they grew older, the kids, Lori and Jeannette especially, started to notice that their parents were struggling
Shut your trap, button your lip, can it. All that crap you hear on TV about communication and expressing feelings is a lie. Nobody really wants to hear what you have to say. " This quote relates to the title of the book "speak" it shows how Melinda believes that she will benefit from being silent. The quote shows that Melinda actually have a voice but only inside her head not anywhere else.
Maureen is highly dependant on others, but as soon as she started to live with her parents. She found out that she couldn’t depend on them anymore. Out of frustration, she stabbed her own mom. Maureen’s self desires were not accomplished. She found no need for her mother, as well as the fact that Maureen was tired of hearing her mom nag her everyday.
This causes her to be unable to speak as normal and express herself only through self physical acts of hurting herself. However, through her pain, she begins to grow from a victim to a survivor and understands that the only way to go against evil is to speak out against it. Melinda in Speak is a high school freshman who is raped by Andy Evans who is a senior in high school. Due to him raping her she loses her ability to speak normally and say what she feels and how she feels. Melinda gains her confidence to speak in public freely again by the end of the story.
Melinda’s parents are workers and come home at late hours of the night and head straight to bed. They never notice their daughter struggling which meant no one reached out to her, allowing her PTSD to go unnoticed and without help. Melinda kept to herself and did not share her feelings because she grew up watching her parents keep to themselves and not seek out help, children tend to do what they have watched their parents do.
" Speak also states on page 161 " I am a deer in headlights of a tractor, is he going to hurt me again? He couldn't in school... why am I so afraid. " These examples from the text show all the problems Melinda had, for instance what Andy did to her,
“Speak”, is the voice of every teenager who has ever encountered bullying, suffering, loneliness, and abandonment. I felt like I knew Melinda personally after learning about her character, I felt understanding and empathy towards her. Something I was really gripped by was Melinda’s decision making process, which made me understand her feelings and reactions towards others. It seems that Melinda had 2 personalities; a careful always alert, depressed goody two shoes, and someone who just wants to have fun, take risks, and be rebellious. Whenever Melinda wanted to make a decision, she picked the cautious side of her; for example, when her friend Heather had asked to paint each other’s nails, Melinda said “no”, even though her 2nd personality tried to convince her to do so, which in my opinion was caused by the “incident”.
Here, James describes how his lies are affecting his mother, causing her to feel like a [failure]. All the other children in her family fit in, but James sticks out. His mother does not only feel as if she has failed the family, she feels she has failed
At the end of the story she finally found her voice and was able to stand up for herself. In the beginning, Melinda didn't talk to anyone, barely even to her parents. She says, “I have tried so hard to forget every second of that stupid party and here I am in the middle of a hostile crowd that hates me for what I had to do. I can't tell them what really happened” (Anderson, 28).
In the story, Melinda got raped from a senior, Andy Evans. They were all at a party one night and he got her on drugs so she couldn’t stop him. She eventually called the police on the party, and everyone got upset with Melinda for getting them in trouble, but none of them knew why she called the police.
When she was young, she could not process the way her father raised and treated her, so she believed everything he said. When she is able to understand, her tone changes and becomes clinical and critical remembering the way he constantly let her
This chapter ends with David being allowed to record what goes on in class practically beating Mr. Neck, and Melinda calls David her hero. Melinda began to feel inspired by what David had done as his act of standing up to Mr. Neck reminded Melinda of her struggle of not being able to speak up about what happened to her. David showed her that speaking up can change things and that people will get what they deserve. Moreover, the chapter “Wishbone” shows that Melinda feels stuck or trapped in the same place. She has so much more to her than she lets on, but it’s all hidden inside because she can’t get herself to speak, it also reveals that she is in a lot of pain.
Although she was trying to get away, if she went back for the gloves “she knew she’d end up staying”(1). Maureen is a pretty distracted person. First of all, she left her gloves in the club. Second of all, “She had gone almost a block when she realized that she was walking in the wrong direction”(1). Maureen, as we learn, is a high school English teacher.
I had to get on the phone and say in an adolescent voice that was not very convincing, ‘This is Mrs. Tan’”(10). This shows how her mother affected her childhood in the way that she even had to talk for her so that other people would understand and take her seriously. The way Tan includes this quote shows that as a child she had to help her mom in many major ways. With this quote Tan affects the audience in the way that just because she was ashamed of her mother doesn’t mean that she didn’t care for her and that other people should do the same. “My mother had gone to the hospital for an appointment, to find out about a benign brain tumor a CAT scan had revealed a month ago.
The family would always ask “why us?” or “maybe it’s a curse” or “she was fine for years”, and the list would go on and on. (225) She didn’t feel like she belonged and her family