What defines a hero? Everyone has their own definition of what a hero should be. Aristotle defines a tragic hero as a character who has; a great reputation, prosperity, a virtuous manner, and a tragic flaw that causes them to make an error in judgement that leads to their misfortune. In the play Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare two men fulfill this criteria. Although both Marcus Brutus and Julius Caesar can be labeled the tragic hero, Brutus goes above and beyond what a tragic hero is. Both Marcus Brutus and Julius Caesar hold great reputations. Brutus was known to the people of Rome as noble and loyal. It is Brutus the conspirators want to join the conspiracy to make their actions seem better than they really are. In one scene Casca …show more content…
Brutus shows integrity through his actions by always making decisions that benefit Rome and the people. It is in one of Brutus’s soliloquies that he states what Caesar’s reign would look like and then further explains his reasons for wanting to kill Caesar. He uses the illustration of Caesar being climbing a ladder and only looking up into what is next never bothering to look back to the people who helped him get there (II.1.10-36). This displays Brutus’s Virtue by displaying his true reasons for deciding to take part in Caesar’s death. It is in Brutus’s thoughts that his virtue really shows owing to the fact that his actions are always justified. Virtuous people always doo what is best even when it doesn’t benefit them. Caesar shows integrity through giving to the people of Rome. When Antony is reading from Caesar’s will he describes how Caesar felt about the people by calling them “heirs” . Caesar then decided to leave the people a good amount of money and community land (III.2.241-242). A person who is full of virtue or goodness tends to give more than receive ,which is what Caesar did. He could of kept this money for himself and not have bothered to leave anything for his people but he
According to Aristotle, a tragic hero takes on many characteristics. The first of which is to be virtuous. A tragic hero must be high in the totem pole. They must be a noble citizen of society and are usually viewed as a hero. This hero must be held culpable of the responsibilities of the town.
Who is a hero? A hero takes many forms, such as an allegorical hero, a tragic hero, or an epic hero. In the age of postmodernism, there are instances where a person can be both a hero and a villain. Odysseus is difficult to identify as a hero because of his many vices.
Was Brutus Noble? In Shakespeare 's’ The Tragedy Of Julius Caesar, one of the main characters, Marcus Brutus, is found dead by the noble Mark Antony, and is called “The Noblest Roman Of Them All” (Julius Caesar Act 5, scene 5, 68–72). Antony 's’ statement is a true one for many reasons. The first reason would be that Brutus was a man who valued his friendships over all else.
What is a tragic hero? The most well know definition is a good person who makes a (stupid) mistake that leads to his/her tragic downfall. A perfect example of this comes from Arthur Miller’s play The Crucible. We see this through the one of the characters who got trapped in his own conscience about whether or not to save his name from being spread all over Salem. In the play, a farmer, John Proctor is committed for witchery (which he never did) by Abigail, a girl who he had an affair with.
During the meeting with the Conspirators at his home, Brutus says to them, “No, not an oath” (II.i.125) because “what other oath” is better “than honesty to honesty engaged” (II.i.137-138). Brutus believes they do not need to pledge an oath because he already thinks they are loyal to Rome and that none of them will “palter”. Even before getting to know the rest of the conspirators, he already assumes that they are all there to plan the assassination of Caesar in order to make Rome a better place. All the conspirators, excluding Brutus, have a personal reason on why they want to kill Caesar, whether it is out of envy or pure hatred, but Brutus does not see that they harbor strong resentment towards Caesar. When the conspirators were talking about killing Caesar, Cassius brings up that they should kill Antony too, but Brutus dismisses that notion by claiming that “Antony is but a limb of Caesar” (II.i.179).
One’s integrity represents their true character, and treason shows lack of trust and allegiance. Brutus turns to an entirely different person than he used to be, after he murders Caesar. Clearly, he lacks core values as a respected man. In Act 4, Scene 3, Brutus defends his actions and attempts to justify his sin: “Did not great Julius bleed for justice' sake?” Although Brutus was good friends with Caesar, he seems to disregard all of it.
What makes this all worse is that the conspirators want to take over Rome which will make everything worse in the end. Finally, this is why Brutus is the least honorable character. Brutus is the least honorable character because he killed Julius Caesar. He made Caesar think they were friends just to betray him in the
Examples of ethos were used to show Brutus’ honorability, and that he had the good of Rome in mind when he planned to
The literary definition of a tragic hero is a person that thinks they have to save the day, but their flaw ends up getting them killed, which sets up most of the plays Shakespeare wrote . Shakespeare's tragedy Hamlet is no exception it is about Hamlet trying to avenge his father’s death. When he figures out Claudius, the new king, killed him Hamlet was furious. Hamlet went on trying to kill Claudius to avenge his father’s death. In doing so leaving a huge mess in his wake.
The best way to show honor is being honorable to a cause. Brutus is more honorable than Antony because he is selfless for a good cause, is concerned for the future of Rome, and he is fearful for what Caesar might do to Rome. Antony is honorable because he is loyal to Caesar, he is cunning and he manipulated the conspirators. Antony is loyal to Caesar because even after Caesar was dead Antony continued to praise him. "Thou art the ruins of the noblest man/That ever lived in the tide of times" (3,i,256-257)
And while Brutus did work in part with other conspirators, which eventually led to him killing Caesar, he did it for a more morally sound reason which was that Caesar was going to cause the downfall of Rome because he was too ambitious, which is ironic because Caesar's death led to a string of unfit leaders, and civil unrest that eventually led to the downfall of the roman empire. Brutus was also focused on preventing corruption. “The name of Cassius honors this corruption,/ And chastisement doth therefore hide his head (IV.iii.15-6)... Remember March, the ides of March remember./ Did not great Julius bleed for justice' sake” (IV.iii.18-9).
People complain that Brutus is just as bad as Caesar, yet Brutus does it for justice of the people. While others explain that the Roman empire will fall due to Brutus’s actions, others will say that he has a high respect of the citizens, and the citizens would know he did the deed for the better good. While some may bicker about Brutus making predictions about the future, he is simply trying to prevent tyranny to get ahold of Rome and the empire. Brutus is the perfect example of anyone in the world, who wants to do the better good for everyone. Should Brutus join the conspiracy against Caesar?
Honor in the world gives people a reason to fight for the things that they believe in. Throughout The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, Brutus has had to make many tough decisions that display the great honor within him. In The Tragedy of Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare's, it is made very obvious that Brutus is an honorable man. Brutus preserves his honor by taking care of Rome’s issues with good intentions and without going too far.
Brutus, does not have the arrogant stubbornness of Caesar, rather he makes authoritative decisions without regard to other opinions. His unwillingness to compromise can be seen in the why he assumes command and makes decisions once becoming a member of the conspirators. Immediately after enlisting in the conspiracy Brutus, who was not elected leader, aggressively takes command of the conspiracy and makes a series of decisions despite differing opinions from every other member of the group. In Act II Scene 1, the conspiracy gathers together to plot their attack on Caesar, and Brutus immediately takes command. The group asks if they should swear an oath, have Cicero join the conspiracy, or kill Mark Antony.
An Aristotelian tragic hero is a character born of noble birth and, by destiny, has a tragic flaw that inevitably leads to his or her downfall and redeems his or herself by the end of the tragedy. For one to consider a play a tragedy, the character of the play must be noble, and the play typically starts off with happiness and wealth. The play ends with sadness and the hero has a tragic flaw that causes their downfall. In The Tragedy of Macbeth by William Shakespeare, Macbeth fits the definition of an Aristotelian tragic hero. Macbeth is a tragic hero because he starts by being loyal and trustworthy, develops a tragic flaw that leads to his downfall, and he redeems a small measure of himself before he dies.