The Tragedy of Markus Brutus In the play The Tragedy of Julius Caesar many believe that obviously the tragic hero of the play is Julius Caesar but the real tragic hero of the play is Markus Brutus. A tragic hero is one who experiences a traumatic downfall that comes in three stages. Brutus possesses all three stages such as the fatal flaw, a decision that leads to their own destruction, and experience peripeteia (sudden change in fortune). These reasons make Brutus the tragic hero and not Caesar. Every tragic hero has a fatal flaw and Brutus is no exception. Brutus’s fatal flaw is that he believes everyone is trustworthy and honorable just like him. He is taken advantage of by multiple people in the story because of his gullible nature. More notably by Cassius who manipulates Brutus into becoming the leader of the conspirators using a couple very effective tactics. Cassius forges letters, tells him what he wants to hear, and convinces Brutus that Caesar must die. Brutus blindly listens to Cassius and leads him to make the decision that leads to his destruction. …show more content…
When the conspirators come to Brutus’s house to discuss the assassination Cassius proposes that they kill Mark Antony as well as Caesar but Brutus vetoes the idea saying that once they kill Caesar Antony will cower away. Brutus was right about this assumption for the most part for when Caesar was assassinated Antony ran off and sent his servant out to see if it was safe for him to come out. Antony talks with Brutus and shakes his hand, seemingly joining Brutus and accepting him. Antony lies straight to Brutus’s face and Brutus had no idea another example of his gullible nature. Antony is an opportunist and wants revenge for the killing of Caesar so he turns the people against Brutus and begins building an army to challenge
People would view brutus as rogue and a scoundrel. But the truth is is he was blinded by cassius that caesar turn rome’s citizens into worshippers of caesar and his bloodline. forever abolishing Rome’s religion Cassius used brutus to kill caesar and save rome. But it proved that brutus valued rome over the friendship with him and caesar. The aftermath of the assassination of leads to brutus and the others killing themselves in the battle.
Brutus’ character, conflict about killing Caesar, and loyalty to Rome make him the tragic hero in The Tragedy of Julius Caesar. One of the main reasons Brutus is the tragic hero of the play is because of his character. Brutus is very popular among the people of Rome because of his nobility and honor. All of his views are guided by the sense of honor and dignity, but with this tunnel vision he becomes naive. “Which so appearing to the common eyes, / We shall be called purgers, not murderers.
Many people who have read this play think that Caesar may be the tragic hero. Which makes sense since he has power and happiness in the beginning, he has a flaw of ambition and it leads to his death. But the true tragic hero is Brutus, everyone loves him,he has power and his wife Portia who completed his happiness,
Brutus was a flawed man in many ways in that he was to arrogant he let Marc Antony have a speech even though Antony was conspiring against him the whole time gaining the crowds approval. Brutus says “ Tending to Caesar’s glories which Marc Antony by our permission, is allowed to make” (1250). This is a blatant point to Brutus’ arrogance, he thought that Antony is no threat and trusted him to much. After Antony made this speech the entire crowd turned against Brutus and the conspirators. If Brutus was not so arrogant he would be most likely be alive.
Just as being easily manipulated did, Brutus always trusting everyone led to his downfall. He trusted his closest friends, when they were actually lying to
A character who makes a judgement or error that inevitably leads to his or her own destruction, defines a tragic hero, according to Aristotle. In William Shakespeare’s writings, one character generally identifies as a tragic hero. Shakespeare’s play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, comes from the true events that took place in Rome during the time that Caesar rose and gained power as dictator. After Pompey’s death in Egypt, caused by each of their power-hungry desires, Caesar declared himself dictator of Rome. Although, with Pompey’s death, many remained loyal to him as opposed to Caesar, that then led to the plot of Caesar’s assassination.
When he possesses this fatal flaw, he makes poor judgment that leads to his own destruction. Brutus is extremely naive. After he and the Conspirators killed Caesar, his downfall started. Brutus deserves the title of a Tragic Hero over Caesar because of his noble personality.
This could be true, but Brutus would fit more into the tragic hero persona. Some of Brutus’s tragic flaws included trusting people too much, not listening to others that have more experience, and thinking about the people more than himself. All of these flaws ultimately led to Brutus becoming a coward and committing suicide. In act 3 scene 1 Brutus kills Caesar because he thinks he is doing it for the good of Rome. In reality, when he killed Caesar he just signed his death note, and he hurt Rome more than helped.
/ Why should that name be sounded more than yours[, Brutus]” (I, ii, 142-143). From this conversation, Brutus is shown to let his naive and too trusting personality overcome him to the point he could be guided by his close friends as seen with Cassius in following whatever path they consider to be noble. Moreover, Brutus is shown to have a weak personality, a characteristic of a tragic hero, since he is easily persuaded in following Cassius’s idea that Caesar is indeed not fit to rule Rome as an emperor and should be taken down, and this naivety of his leads to his own downfall by trusting the wrong person. In addition, due to this tragic flaw, he is taken advantage of by his friends. For instance, when Brutus trusts the words of Mark Antony, a man who is very loyal to Caesar and hates the conspirators who killed Caesar, as Brutus asks him to promise that he “shall not in [his] funeral speech blame [the conspirators]” (III, i, 245) to which Antony, taking advantage of Brutus’s flaw, says “[b]e it so, I do desire no more” (III, i, 253), but as Antony does his speech, he describes
Proving a Tragic Hero A character who makes a judgement or error that inevitably leads to his or her own destruction, defines a tragic hero, according to Aristotle. In William Shakespeare’s writings, one character generally identifies as a tragic hero. Shakespeare’s play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, comes from the true events that took place in Rome during the time that Caesar rose and gained power as dictator. After Pompey’s death in Egypt; caused by each of their power-hungry desires, Caesar declared himself dictator of Rome.
Although Brutus loved Caesar, he still chose his people who were in “danger” because of Caesar. Cassius' desire for Brutus to be part of the conspirators stems from his honorable reputation as a citizen of Rome. In addition to this, Brutus' honor prevented him from killing Antony,
Brutus’s tragic flaw was that he was naive. He trusted people to easily, especially the conspirators. They used him to make their actions seem honorable and just. When reality they just wanted Caesar dead for their own personal gain. Caesar was Brutus’s friend so it took him some convincing for him to be able to justify his actions.
Brutus, does not have the arrogant stubbornness of Caesar, rather he makes authoritative decisions without regard to other opinions. His unwillingness to compromise can be seen in the why he assumes command and makes decisions once becoming a member of the conspirators. Immediately after enlisting in the conspiracy Brutus, who was not elected leader, aggressively takes command of the conspiracy and makes a series of decisions despite differing opinions from every other member of the group. In Act II Scene 1, the conspiracy gathers together to plot their attack on Caesar, and Brutus immediately takes command. The group asks if they should swear an oath, have Cicero join the conspiracy, or kill Mark Antony.
Brutus also contains several other characteristics of a tragic hero. For example, Brutus possesses a hamartia. “Th’ abuse of greatness is when it disjoins/ Remorse from power; and, to speak truth of Caesar” (Shakespeare II.1.18-19). In this quote from the story, Brutus is saying that he believes Caesar would abuse the power of being crowned king.
He has realised his faults so clearly that he tells Caesar, the person he killed, to rest in peace. Brutus is definitely the tragic hero in this play because of the pity we feel for his realisation of his faults and ultimately his honourable