The question is, “Should kids get a trophy for showing up?” I would have to say that they shouldn’t get a trophy for just showing up. What is the point of getting a trophy if you don’t actually do anything. I would agree that they ones that do show up and actually do something, should get a trophy, but to say if kids that show just show should get a trophy is something else. If someone were to play basketball and they didn’t do anything they shouldn’t be able participate in the sport, it is ridiculous to give a trophy to someone that isn’t doing anything.
First of all, would have to say that I agree but then I really don’t really agree with the whole trophy thing. I would have to say that it is a good idea to give them a reward for participating in the game or whatever it is they are doing, but to give them a trophy? I, personally think it is too much, plus not every kid participates in the activity and sometimes they are only there because they are forced to associate with other children. For example, my brother loves to play basketball, soccer but hates to play
…show more content…
There is this quote by Nancy Pearcey that says, “Competition is always a good thing. It forces us to do our best. A monopoly renders people complacent and satisfied with mediocrity.” That quote would motivate me to do my best in anything in order to get that trophy. It makes me what to fight for what I deserve and not to just have it given to me. Competing for something is a lot more fun than just sitting around and not doing anything. Kids now are so lazy, all they want to do is play video games or sit and watch TV. Kids shouldn’t have to live that life, they should be out having fun and earning something other than earning points on a stupid video game. No kid is going to have any competition with anyone if they just sit on theirs butts and just lounge around. No kid is going to be competitive is they don’t enjoy
Trophies being rewarded/not being rewarded can be a serious factor upon kids today as stated in the passages. In the article Participation Trophies Send a Dangerous Message By Betty Berden shows the kids shouldn’t be given a trophy unless they have worked for it and not for just being on the team. Being on a sports team can show a lot of kids what they would want to succeed but the accomplishment is key to how they feel about it after they win. The students that did not come in a high rank or didn’t put just enough work in to win should not receive any kind of trophy but the ones who came in a high place for their skill and hard work should receive a trophy to show their accomplishment. The kids that are just on the team and put just enough
TITLE Has your kid been trying as hard as they used to? If not it’s probably because they know they will automatically get a participation trophy no matter what. A debate has been raging about if there should be participation trophies for sports. I am on the side that is against participation trophies. Participation trophies aren’t the brightest thing to do, here are 3 reasons why I think so.
In that interview it shows that kids purposefully played on easier levels to stand out, which is dangerous. Kids want to stand out, and that doesn’t happen if everyone gets a participation
Should youth athletes receive participation trophies? According to the " Trophies for All" policy, youth athletes are being rewarded with participation trophies. This isn't fair to youth athletes. An athlete that only does what is required shouldn't be rewarded the same as an athlete that helps the team much more. Another reason why participation trophies are unnecessary is because after being given so many participation rewards, the eventually begin to lose their value.
If you join a club or team of course you will have to participate, and you should not get a trophy for it. Participation trophies are dangerous because not only do trophies overlook true achievement but it sends a dangerous message. In the article it states that, “Trophies for all convey an inaccurate and potentially dangerous life message to children:
without competition people wont work for their goals, they will simply adopt the mentality that they get a prize no matter what. The real world dose 't work like that. Schools are supposed to prepare you for the next step in life, Not drag you down. major sports dont give participation points and the players are non the worse for it. Finally, trophies for participation is an absolutely ridiculous idea and it should be
“Kids will feel like winners. ”This is what 40% of Americans say to participation trophies. One big reason why the concept is lost is when kids that got first, second, and third place have to deal with other kids getting medals or trophies. Awards should only be given out when true achievement is accomplished. ” But every time we give our children an award for something they didn't legitimately achieve, we're doing them a disservice that can last significantly longer than the high of receiving the award.”
With the main question being, is it good to give out the trophies or not? Personally I am against the idea of giving participation trophies. Participation trophies should not be given out for many reasons. One being that the trophies will lose their meaning after a while. According to Hilary Levey Friedman a sociologist and author of “Playing to Win: Raising Children in a Competitive Culture” said, “ kids are even smarter
In today’s society, more and more kids are getting participation trophies for doing nothing except showing up. Yes it is important to teach kids to do their best, but being awarded just for being as good as you already are doesn't give kids the motivation to make themselves even better. Why would they want to improve if they already have that shiny trophy? I do not believe that participation trophies should be handed out like they are.
I believe that participation trophies are a great thing to be rewarded, but ton only younger kids, here’s why. There are many reasons why people believe that participation trophies should not be given out to younger athletes. However, I believe that younger athletes below the age of ten should always be rewarded
Should Children Receive Trophies Just For Participating? What are trophies? They are memorable tokens that symbolize hard work and excellence. They are symbols of winners who worked hard to try and reach their goal.
Participation trophies diminish the meaning of winning and produce a lack of motivation among our youth today. Though rewarding all players with a trophy is counteractive, positive reinforcement is not. Positive reinforcement is key in the process of encouraging adolescents to continue to pursue the sport they are playing. The winners should receive a trophy to endorse their hard work and accomplishment; those who lost, but kept playing, should receive a non-materialistic item such as a pizza party or ice cream to acknowledge their determination when playing the game. Without loss, there is no motive to
Why should we raise our children up to believe that just because they showed up to the event they deserve a trophy? We are teaching them that losing is so awful that we can’t let it happen, so everyone gets to be a winner. As a society, we should not give children participation trophies because it is teaching them to accept failure. Trophies
It becomes more about beating their opponents and winning rather than having fun. Fun must be a part of most activities if children are going to continue to participate willingly. With the new responsibilities that are given to a child as they enter Middle School and their early teens, they find their priorities shifting. Life starts to get a bit more serious, and unless the dedication to compete on the playing field is deeply rooted, it will be dropped from the curriculum faster than stinky gym shoes. When a kid doesn’t have the talent that he or she needs to make first string, first chair, first line-up then they begin to question themselves.
It can’t be done. And it’s OK for kids to want to win” (Turner). Many believe that eliminating competition is the only choice. However, the motivation to win is extremely important and can never be fully eliminated. “By suppressing competition, we are failing to prepare the next generation for the realities of the world” (Pandel).