The American Revolution and the French Revolution are two phenomenal topics to consider. When you go in depth into these topics, you may notice that they have many differences, but they also have many similarities. In my opinion, these concepts should be considered more alike than they are different. We should acknowledge that there are many differences and they did occur at many different parts of history, but in the concepts we find many similarities. By exploring the American Revolution and the French Revolution, we will see the many similarities.
The American Revolution started out with the colonists wanting to escape the monarchy to be in the new world. Unfortunately, the British didn’t make it easy on the colonists. Initially they supported
…show more content…
The British issued the Stamp Act of 1765. According to our textbook, the act levied taxes for the colonists. Because of this, many resorted to rioting. These two groups both envisioned a different form of an empire. Our textbook tells us that “the British envisioned a single empire with Parliament as the supreme authority throughout.” They wanted Parliament to make all the laws for the people, including the colonists. The Americans on the other hand had representative assemblies. Their belief was “that neither king nor Parliament had any right to interfere in their internal affairs and that no tax could be levied without the consent of the people or their chosen representatives.” (Spielvogel) This is when the colonists decided they needed to make a change. They decided it was time to become an independent nation. The Second Continental congress met to create the “Declaration of Independence”. In the Declaration, the colonists are promised that their natural …show more content…
Even though the monarch was against it, he was forced to summon the Estates General. It was merely summoned to find a solution to this financial problem. Little did he know that the Estates General was attempting to take more power than they were initially supposed to have. They declared themselves as the “National Assembly” and were pushing to form a constitution. For their next meeting they arrived to find the door locked. The king attempted to dissolve them, but the common people responded by storming the Bastille. Following this, many peasants decided to rebel. The National Assembly created a new constitution. Even though Louis XVI was already incredibly inactive, this limited the power of the monarch. It also created a National Convention with representatives from each estate. One day, the National Convention was meeting to talk about foreign policies. Groups that had initially aligned with France wanted to invade France to bring Europe back to the Old Regime. The Convention decided to put power in the hands of the Committee of Public Safety, led by Maximilien Robespierre. These leaders organized a “Reign of Terror”. The goal of this was to remove the corruption. In Robespierre’s speech, he says that “when the people itself is corrupted, liberty is already lost.” In order to maintain their government they must be free of corruption. This group became more excessive with their power than
An overthrow of the government seemed to be a thing of the late seventeen and early eighteen hundreds as quite a few revolutions took place. In particular, the American, French and then shortly thereafter following the Haitian revolution all took place during this time span. Each group initially achieved their goals, however, each victory achieved came through many different grades of success. Each revolution shares an adequate amount of similarities, however, differences are pronounced and seen throughout each revolt as well. To begin, The American, French, and Haitian revolts were all nourished from philosophical ideas of the enlightenment.
Two revolutions, both taking place in the 18th Century, both world-changing. People heavily associate the French Revolution with the American Revolution, due to the many general similarities. However, there are crucial differences that led to their respective results and their long-term impact. How did these events begin? America's reasons began as grievances lodged against taxation.
The American Revolution and the French Revolution were a large part of the 1700’s, changing citizens’ rights to be free and equal, thus resulting in how we live today. It is necessary for one to acquire knowledge of these events in our past to make sense of why we are the way we are today. Both wars had the same main ideas and purpose, but there are details and factors that are different, still each thrived and prospered in their goals for freedom. The similarities America and France had in their Revolutions included the early events and causes, excellent military leaders who led them to success, and the documents made such as The Declaration of Independence and The Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen.
The American and French Revolution were both inspired by a desire for democracy, yet each occurred under different historical circumstances. Both sides had different goals but they also had similar goals. The Americans had little say in the government and wanted that to change that. They also wanted to get rid of taxation without representation. The French also wanted the three classes to have more equality.
Before the American Revolution the thirteen colonies were a part of the British Empire. They had to pay for many of the Britain’s things such as taxes. They weren’t treated as great as the British and had to pay a lot of money. This was a major cause of the American Revolution. The Americans were getting tired of British rule and wanted to be free, or not ruled by the emperor.
The French nobles, Bourgeoisie, and peasants wanted to break away because the people wanted more power, to overthrow the monarchy, or to change the tax system. The American and French Revolution both have similarities and differences. The similarities and differences come in economy, leaders, ideology, and provocation. The American Revolution was started basically because of problems
2.The french and american revolution had many similarities at the time. The causes were the same,they both had unequal rights and they both had to raise their
The enlightenment improved by human action in the Atlantic Region through political arrangements that were engineered. Liberty, free trade, equality, rationality, sovereignty through popularity, natural rights, and others provided the underpinnings for the following revolutions in world history. The American revolution was so revolutionary compared to the Other Revolutions because the American revolution was Marked as a Political Change, meaning policies and other aspects of politics were changes instead of the other way to do it, as well as it worked to preserve the freedoms of the already existing colonies to better everyone's lives Unlike the American Revolution, the French one had a driving force of conflict throughout the french society. The french Revolution had a significant amount
American Vs. French. Revolutions, that is. Wars are all similar, and different, in many ways but just what is so different about the French and American revolutions, even though they happened around the same time? Besides the obvious of the two being different nationalities, the French actually started with a civil war and evolved into the French fighting with other monarchies around Europe, while the American revolutions stayed mostly between Britain and the colonies until the French joined in 1778.
Another important similarity between the two revolutions in France and America was their emphasis on Enlightenment thought. The first of these ideas is the idea of popular sovereignty. This is the idea that governments were only legitimate if they got their powers from the consent of the people. It also holds that the people should have the ultimate power over their government. Both the French and American Revolutions were based in large part on the desire to take power away from aristocratic elites and give that power to the people.
History is made everywhere, we just don 't take it into consideration as much. Today, i 'll be explaining the differences and similarities about the French and American Revolution. The French Revolution had three estates which were first estate (church clergy), second estate (nobility and the rest of the French people), and the third estate (urban lower class and peasant farmers). They went through a lot, mostly because of debt and unfairness. The American Revolution began with the Enlightenment, which was a movement that looked at government and science and that later traced the French and Indian War which was a war on the ocean that was a conflict that brought many colonists into direct combat for the sake of the English king.
After three centuries of colonial rule, Spanish and Portuguese America got independence. Between 1808 and 1826 all of Latin America except the Spanish colonies of Cuba and Puerto Rico remained under Spanish rule. This was the result of a combination of long-building tensions in colonial rule and a series of external events. The reforms imposed by the Spanish in the 18th century provoked great instability in the relations between the rulers and their colonial subjects in the Americas. Many Creoles felt Bourbon policy to be an unfair attack on their wealth, political power, and social status.
The British government was not looking for the best of the people. They were only thinking about what they wanted; the government was not interested in what the people wanted so they decided to make decisions on their own, which resulted in changes that form the United States today. Because of this, they were justified in rebelling and declaring independence. One reason why the colonists decided to rebel and declare independence was because of taxation.
The people of America (colonists) were tired of being controlled by England. They wanted to be free and independent. They believed that they were able to control themselves and be their own country. They wanted England to let go of their control and to view them as independent and their own country.
The first way that the French Revolution in the late 1700s and the Russian Revolution in the early 1900s compare is their government. During their times, they both had weak leaders that did not desire to rule, this was King Louis XVI of France and Czar Nicholas II of Russia. Both Royal families were eventually executed or assassinated. Also, both countries around the time of their revolutions were affected by a war in a way, the American Revolution for France and World War I for Russia. Both tried new governments, for France this was democracy and for Russia it was communism.