The Unfairness of Athletics Over the past one-hundred years, sports have become one of America’s most beloved past times. Sports have also become a great opportunity for young athletes to create friendships, while learning valuable life lessons. However, in the last decade, the attention of sports has been directed away from developing children and young adults into superior athletes and helping them achieve personal goals, to assuring that no athlete feels left out when trophy day arrives. Perhaps the most controversial issue in the world of sports today is the debate over whether or not participation trophies should be given to athletes for merely coming to practice and playing games. The argument is what many people would refer to as a two-way street. While there are some people who believe that participation trophies are beneficial to the self-esteem and confidence of athletes, there are others who believe that a trophy should be earned, not …show more content…
For athletes across the world, a trophy, medal, or plaque that is awarded to them for excelling in sports is a landmark achievement to say the least. Most athletes who are presented with an award, generally cherish and appreciate their accomplishment, but if all athletes are awarded with a trophy or medal for only coming to practice, then the value of athletic awards diminish. Giving out awards to young athletes for only coming to practice and participating in athletic events, can present some negative consequences in the future. For instance, if an athlete receives a participation trophy at the end of every season, then the athlete will begin to develop the mindset that he or she is entitled to an award, regardless if the athlete truly deserves the award or not. This type of behavior can send a negative message to younger generations of athletes who are beginning their athletic
Throughout the article “Participations Trophies Send a Dangerous Message”, by Betty Berden, she talks about her own history in the collection of trophies. In paragraph 1 Mrs. Berden introduces the reader to the danger of participation trophies, “They do not mean much to me because I know that identical trophies sit in other children’s rooms all over town…”, the author describes her own personal life and experience with the trophies. Mrs. Berden explains how she has received such a large quantity of participation trophies that they now mean very little to her because they require very little to achieve. Written in paragraph 2 the author explained, “Regardless of individual effort or superior skills, all who participate receive equal acknowledgement. “,should it be fair for one person to excel and go above the rest but everybody receives the praise?
Many people contend that children should receive participation trophies in sports, however, why should they not get one? Kids who truly deserve to be awarded won't feel as special, seeing as you can get an award without putting in the effort. Although the participation award can make them feel involved, it shouldn't be granted to them as it can value less of an incentive and responsibility. Children in sports should not get a participation trophy for their attendance, and attitude toward the activity. The author Corey Turner of the article, "Should Kids Get A Trophy For Showing Up?" conveys a message about why kids should not get a trophy.
Whenever your child plays a sport, you would want them to get a trophy, but if they don't do anything and still receive a trophy, then they are being set up for failure. In the real world, you will not earn anything from doing nothing, but when your child receives a trophy for doing nothing, they are being taught that they don't need to do anything and they will still be rewarded. Firstly, participation trophies show kids that all they need to do the rest of their lives is just show up and they will do good. When kids play a sport, you want them to get a trophy for winning, not for just being there and participating.
The celebration of the end of your sport season is so exciting you could probably burst with joy but you have to wait after the awards. People have been talking about how participation trophies are good for the kids or bad for them. I think that participation trophies should be given to the kids. There are different reasons why participation trophies are good.
No, participation trophies shouldn't be given because of the negative effects it has had on athletes, coaches, and parents. Why should we reward kids for participation trophies when they don’t
However, to many parents of youth athletes, there are also many benefits to being given these trophies. Youth athletes should not be rewarded for simply doing what is required. Many parents and youth athletes believe that participation trophies are not fair for the team. In the article," Does Sports Participation Deserve A Trophy," James Harrison states that everyone is not a winner. Some
Coaches believe that giving out trophies to youth athletes will not cause long term damage to them, although extrinsic motivation on its own can be harmful to youth athletes and won't help them at all. Youth athletes shouldn’t be getting awarded for just showing up and participating in activities. Participation trophies are becoming more commonplace today, particularly throughout youth athletes. According to "The Great Trophy Debate" by John O'Sullivan, If kids get participation trophies every time they just show up they are going to lose all meaning. Trophies are supposed to have meanings to them like, they are the most improved in class or they have ran a mile in a short amount of time.
Many athletes around the world always have had the fear of losing or coming up short in the back of their mind. Should it be okay to give out participation trophies to everyone who tries in the game or participates in the tournament? A popular discussion today is if sports participation trophies should be given to everyone who plays. My side of the argument is to not give out participation trophies just for showing up and playing.
You want to raise your kids right, right? Like letting them win something for what so claim that they don’t deserve. Like giving them a participation trophy for not working as hard as they could or just sitting on the field watching the others players play the actual game. The two sides to this debate are for participation trophies because they give them positive influence and against participation trophies because it lowers the child's self-esteem. I am against participation trophies here are my reasons.
You walk into an eight year old’s room, which belongs to a kid name James, and you see trophies stacked in his room everywhere, almost as much as the amount of people there are on the earth. What surprises you is the labels or the purpose of those trophies, like a trophy for “Participation” and a trophy for “Playing a game”, and even a trophy for just Showing up. Realizing that the amount of trophies he has is outweighting his ability in that sport he is in, you realize that the kid is getting so many trophies that are unnecessary and invaluable in terms of the purpose of that trophy or why he got it. Trophies should not be given to everyone involved in that sport because if everyone gets a trophy, they have no value. Also, Sports organizations
In life kids, students, and adults receive awards also trophies for their success in life. When growing up as a child kids will receive participation trophies. Receiving a participation trophy speaks a lot of volume. When getting a participation trophy this means the kid does not have to improve, kids get trophies like candy, and what can people do to change these situation. Giving kids participation trophies is not all good, sometime when doing the best people may fail in today's world.
It’s true how many adults say that kids are easily impressionable and take lead from parents, guardians, or others around them. What kids are taught from a young age can shape how they view the world, act, respond, and even live. Surprisingly, giving a kid a participation trophy in sports is one of those things that many debates about because giving one to them will depend on how their life is shaped and what lessons they are taught. Not giving a kid a participation trophy in sports is more beneficial in teaching them the lessons of proper effort and winning or losing. It also shows how diminishing hard work which can lead to negative outcomes.
Mrs Wooley’s AAU basketball lost the championship but still got a trophy Children should not receive participation trophies. In the passage “Participation Trophies Send a Dangerous Message” by Betty Berden she talks about why children should not get a participation award in a sport or activity. Berden explains and reasons why children should not get a participation award and we should take in consideration that children should not get a participation award.
However, coaches believe participation trophies could be worth a few bucks to bring a smile to kids' faces. No, I do not think all athletes should get a trophy just for showing up. Participation trophies give kids the wrong idea that everything in life is just given to you. If kids want a trophy they should have to work hard and earn one. While I know some kids aren't as skilled as others, it does not mean they are unable to put in an effort to earn an award.
Participation Trophies Should be Prohibited There are many kids that are playing sports , but winning or losing, should they get trophies all the time just for participating? A debate has been raging between whether kids should get participation trophies or not. I think that kids shouldn't get participation trophies just for participating in a sport they may or may not like.