In Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, Brutus’ simple speech during Caesar’s funeral has won the citizens’ over by using logical fallacies such as pathos, ethos, and unsupported claim. In Act 3, scene 2, Brutus’ speech claims that “I rejoice at it; as he was valiant, I honor him; but as he was ambitious, I slew him,”(III, ii, 26-27). Brutus defends himself and the conspirators to the citizens that they killed him to protect Rome from falling back into tyranny. He uses pathos to appeal and play with the citizens’ emotions to convince them that they should be thrilled that the republic has prevented autocracy. In Brutus’ speech, Brutus claims that he loved Rome more than he loved Caesar which is why he killed him; however, this ruins Caesar’s reputation as a good leader. Thus, Brutus uses pathos to convince the citizens that they are not murders, but heroes who prevented tyranny in Rome. …show more content…
During Brutus’ speech, he comments, “Believe me for mine honor, and have respect to mine honor that may believe”(III, ii, 15). Brutus declares that he is the most honorable and noble person in Rome; which is why he murdered Caesar to protect the citizens. Brutus persuades the citizens with his reputation by explaining how he cared about the citizens of Rome, more than Caesar’s well being. He promotes his and the conspirators reputation so they can’t be blamed for Caesar’s death. This leads to the citizens to view them as good leaders for Rome instead of a corrupted government. Nevertheless, Brutus used ethos to appease the citizens of his
During the seminar, many different view points and perspectives were expressed. One of the ideas that were discussed was that Antony and Brutus used different rhetoric devices to express their feelings. Antony used many examples of pathos in both his funeral speech and his everyday life. He aims to establish emotional reactions from his intended audiences and sometimes over uses this device. Brutus on the other hand does the exact opposite.
Julius Caesar Speeches Comparison After the assassination of the Roman leader, Julius Caesar many people were left devastated. The Romans continuously questioned Caesar’s death, which lead to the two men, Mark Antony and Brutus to deliver speeches to the citizens. Brutus gave the citizens a speech with tons of logos to keep the citizens engaged in the beginning, but the tables turned after Antony’s speech. Even though Brutus had a strong impact on the citizens of Rome, Antony grabbed the citizens attention more effectively by showing sympathy for Caesar. Although both of the speeches given were convincing and persuasive, Antony ultimately made a lasting impact because he used pathos when he says “ when that poor have cried, Caesar hath wept”
Furthermore, Brutus demonstrates his love for his country by using pathos in his speech also. He utilizes pathos when he says, “Not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more,” (Shakespeare 3, 2, 11-12). The citizens feel patriotism for their country because Brutus puts
Most times, when one thing is said, two things can be heard. The intent of the speech can be genuine and straightforward, or hidden in double-think and entendre. In Julius Caesar, this is the case with the dichotomy between Brutus and Marc Antony's speeches. the speeches both are given to sway the crowd to one side, and both use the tools of pathos, ethos, and antithesis to lead the country to their rallying cry.
Brutus uses pathos by triggering the emotional feelings of people when he says how much he loved Caesar. He says, “any dear friend of Caesar’s... that Brutus’ love to Caesar
“Julius Caesar,” by William Shakespeares is based on the killing of Julius Caesar and the events that follow his death. After Julius Caesar was killed by a group of men, which included Marcus Brutus and Cassius, two speeches were recited. One by Marc Antony and the other by Marcus Brutus. Both men gave reasonable speeches concerning their side of the situation. The question that has surfaced now is, “How were the speeches similar, but different?”
Brutus was all about honor. The reason he killed Caesar was for honor. Even Antony said that Brutus was “an honourable man.” One of the greatest uses of ethos by Brutus is the quote, “-believe me for mine honour, and have respect to mine honour, that you may believe: censure me in your wisdom, and awake your senses, that you may the better judge.” Brutus used this quote to remind the people how honorable he was.
We Killed This Guy, Let’s Talk About It: A Compare and Contrast Essay Following the death of Julius Caesar, in the play The Tragedy of Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, Caesar’s body is to be presented in front of the crowds of Rome. During this time, the crowds are asked to form an opinion of the assassination from the speeches of Brutus and Mark Antony. Brutus tries to justify the speech claiming though Caesar was good, he was too ambitious while Antony claims this is false and tries to discredit; both utilizing ethos, pathos, and logos for these effects. Both speeches present themselves in a similar way and follow with the argumentative strategies of ethos, pathos, and logos..
Brutus uses more pathos more than anything throughout the argument. He uses a lot of repetition to further express the usage of pathos. For instance, he said, “Not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more... As Caesar loved me, I weep for him… There is tears for his love…”
Brutus uses rhetorical questions, faulty reasoning and hyperboles to create the tone of persuasion while convincing the Roman people to be on his side. To start off his funeral speech, he wants the citizens to trust and believe what he has to say about Caesar, Brutus announces; “Believe me for mine honor, and have respect for my honor, that you may believe me”(Shakespeare 42). In this case, faulty reasoning is shown because Brutus has done nothing to prove him honorable to the citizens. Given that, he has no evidence that he is trustworthy, Brutus still try’s to persuade the crowd to believe what he has to say about Caesar is true, which is
There are many reasons why brutus has the most honor. When Brutus held a meeting at his own house to discuss how they would kill Caesar some of them considered killing Antony as well. Brutus tells them there is no need for this and that if they killed him it would become an act of slaughter instead of justice. Brutus never wavers his side and when he is confronted by Portia on everything he
Also, Brutus explains Caesar has been slain for the welfare of Rome. Anyway, Brutus 's reason for killing Caesar was because of the leaders excessive ambition, then he insults anyone who doesn’t agree with him. Therefore, everyone starts cheering for him and supporting him. Brutus uses pathos to express people’s meaning of love for Rome. also, Brutus committed the crime for
The honorable Brutus, leader of the conspirators, believed no good could come from Caesar’s ambition. When presenting his argument to the people, Brutus included Ethos, a mode of persuasion technique that shows the audience he is a credible, unbiased, source worth listening to. In Act 3 Lines 16-17, Brutus addresses the crowd with the statement that follows, “ If there be any in this assembly, any dear friend of Caesar’s, to him I say that Brutus' love to Caesar was no less than his.”. This statement was included in Brutus's speech to ensure the crowd that there was
Antony uses pathos to create an emotional appeal on the audience. He uses his skills of appealing to the crowds emotion when he persuaded the citizens of Rome that Brutus did not kill Caesar for the good of Rome, but for his personal benefit. Antony states, “The noble Brutus hath told you Caesar was ambitious: if it were so, it was grievous faith and grievously hath
Brutus's speech attempts to justify his actions of stabbing Caesar. He depends greatly on the persuasive appeal of ethics to defend himself and gain the support of the people. The main topic Brutus uses for killing Caesar is "not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more"(3.2.21-22). To others, Brutus is a very honorable man who puts his country before all else because that is what he believes is morally correct. In addition, Brutus pushes his beliefs onto the people by asking "Who is here so rude that would not be a Roman?"(3.2.31-32).