ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of The Monroe Doctrine

1366 Words6 Pages

In the past the United States is known for its notorious habit to take other people’s land. A particular case is Cuba. Cuba was apart of Spain but the United states wanted to capture Cuba and help them gain independence. The action that took place with Panama after a long war and a struggling government the United states also lended a hand to Panama and tried to build the canal. Lending a hand isn’t a problem but when you are trying to take over the country it then becomes a problem. Another action the U.S attempted to take over Panama was to justify it with the Monroe Doctrine. The Monroe Doctrine was a United States policy that was meant to oppose european colonialism and that the U.S would handle the western hemisphere affairs. Despite the …show more content…

In document “”Autopsy of the Monroe Doctrine” by Gaston Nerval talks about a different point of view during this time. Most documents up until now talked about the U.S’s documents and point of view. But this document comes from a point of view from a bolivian journalist and diplomat. In the first sentence it already says the United States policy has a powerful influence on the Latin American policy. “Monroe Doctrine justifies all the aggressive policies of the past. In the eyes of Latin America, it is a pretext for them”(88). The Monroe Doctrine imposes self rights and is easily manipulated to help the United States. The Abandonment of the Monroe Doctrine was a document meant to discard points that might have the U.S misunderstood. The first point in the abandonment of the Monroe Doctrine is that “The Monroe Doctrine was not intended for the benefit of Latin America”(89). This brings up the question about whether or not the Monroe Doctrine supported to claim to the Panama Canal. Another point that is brought up in the abandonment of the Monroe Doctrine is the seventh point “ The Monroe Doctrine has been distorted to serve as an instrument of the hegemony of the United States in the Western Hemisphere”(89). This means that Latin America doesn’t have any rights or benefits from the Monroe Doctrine. The U.S had power and right to establish the

Show More
Related

  • Effects Of The Monroe Doctrine Dbq

    208 Words  | 1 Pages

    The Monroe Doctrine was a threat to European nations for multiple reasons. To begin with, the Monroe Doctrine was a document that was written by John Quincy Adams. The states that were affected by the Monroe Doctrine are the European countries and the independent, smaller countries such as Mexico. The main thesis of the Monroe Doctrine is that America has forbidden Europe from invading other individual countries. The doctrine is a threat because it states that foreign countries are forbidden to enter and colonize land in the western hemisphere.

    Read More

  • Monroe Doctrine Vs Manifest Destiny Essay

    516 Words  | 3 Pages

    The strictness of the United States is exemplified through The American YAWP, which states, “The Monroe Doctrine declared that the United States considered its entire hemisphere, both North and South American, off-limits to new European colonization” (YAWP 193). The United States was sending a strong message, deeming any action even in Latin America would be considered a hostile act against the United States, prompting the United States to take action, which would lead to negative repercussions for the European powers. This Doctrine was issued as a result of growing American concerns about possible increased European powers and prevalence in the Western Hemisphere, specifically the United States (Western United States) through the expansion of their colonies. The

    Read More

  • The Monroe Doctrine Dbq

    105 Words  | 1 Pages

    His most famous piece of legislature, the Monroe Doctrine, came at a time when Eurasia was in a state of turmoil. In 1821, the Russian Tzar, Alexander I, declared that any territory above the 51st parallel would belong solely to Russia. This was an enormous threat for the sovereignty of the young United States since Russia colonized and governed Alaska since 1784 and had begun expanding southward toward the Oregon territory. Moreover, the Tzar banned any foreign ships from coming closer than 115 miles off the coast of the “Russian America”. and claimed a monopoly on fur hunting, fishing, and all trading in that region.

    Read More

  • Open Door Policy Dbq Analysis

    488 Words  | 2 Pages

    During the late nineteenth century and early twentieth century United States main goal was to imperialize other territories. After the Spanish- American War, the United States became an imperialist power by annexing the Philippines, Puerto Rico, Hawaii and Samoa. Americans also developed overseas trade with China and Japan. The United States proposition was to expand their region because they wanted to influence other nations for new trading locations, more resources and the increase of military protection. In spite of the fact that they had the same proposition, their political and economical motives were departed.

    Read More

  • How Did James Monroe Influence The Era Of Good Feelings

    711 Words  | 3 Pages

    Monroe achieved in preserving and furthering the liberty Americans strived for, as well as expanding the size of the U.S. By signing the Florida Purchase Treaty, Monroe managed to gain Spanish Florida as well as setting a larger border by signing the Treaty of 1818. In addition to broadening America’s border’s, James’s legendary Monroe Doctrine boosted America’s freedom and stature to a great extent. The Monroe Doctrine made a great change to America’s foreign policy - it declared an end to European nations colonizing or interfering with states in North or South

    Read More

  • Spanish American War Dbq

    477 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Spanish American War was a big step towards American War power and influenced foreign countries greatly with trade, naval power, and territory. The Era of the Spanish - American contributed to the advancement in trade for the United States. After the Hay-Pauncefote treaty with Britain was abolished, the U.S. was free to build a canal in Latin America with their help. The canal was set to be built in Panama, this canal was to benefit America to create ports free from tax in this country. This was granted when the Hay-Bunau-Varilla Treaty of 1903 gave rights over a 51 mile long and 10 mile wide Canal Zone to protect the U.S. With these rights American manufacturing exporting companies without any tariffs for the citizens of the States.

    Read More

  • Annexed The Philippines

    634 Words  | 3 Pages

    Should The U.S. Have Annexed The Philippines? When the Spanish-American war came to an end and Spain gave up their power in the Philippines and Cuba, the US showed they had no interest in annexing Cuba but were debating on whether or not they should annex the Philippines. The possibility of annexation pleased some but it also made other unhappy, like Emilio Aguinaldo who wanted the Philippines to be free from colonization.

    Read More

  • War Of 1812 Outline

    1277 Words  | 6 Pages

    - As European powers continued to try to gain influence over the Americans, Monroe issued a doctrine that would effectively define American foreign policy for a century. - Monroe’s Doctrine established that the Europeans would stay out of America. - As for the Americans, Monroe stated that they would not get involved in European political affairs. - Monroe’s Doctrine

    Read More

  • How Did Us Foreign Policy Changes Between 1920 And 1941

    595 Words  | 3 Pages

    Nostra heard about the Monroe Doctrine and had some idea to change it up. Ithad no more of it to be used solely for economic dominance and imperialism by the United States, but in conjunction with its twenty neighbors, to defend the collective security of the Western Hemisphere. But changing the Monroe Doctrine only changed some of its power. Still, the Monroe Doctrine could still have advance American economic and political interests in the Western

    Read More

  • United States Expansionism

    900 Words  | 4 Pages

    It was their claim that the expansionists were destroying the “America institutions”, the constitution. On these grounds they tried to prevent the further war and bloodshed in the Philippines and other countries that might bear the same fate in the future if America continued to expand. (Docs A, D) The departure from expansionism was relatively small during this time period while its continuation and progression flourished.

    Read More

  • The Monroe Doctrine

    825 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Monroe Doctrine was a speech given in 1823 by James Monroe, the 5th president of the United States, to the U.S. Congress concerning European presence in the Western Hemisphere. Monroe was becoming continuously concerned about European influence in the region. While the primary audience for this message was Congress, the intended audience was all European powers, including Russia, and Latin America. The events in Latin America before and after the Spanish-American War will be used as an example of the imperial reach by the U.S. The United States, ironically, became an imperial power through its mission outlined in the Monroe Doctrine to end European colonialism and imperialism.

    Read More

  • Imperialism In The 20th Century

    1223 Words  | 5 Pages

    In the next two hundred years, the United States would break away from being a British colony, and instead begin to expand to other areas. America’s belief in expansion was further developed by the Monroe Doctrine of 1823, which declared America to be the protector of the west. Furthermore, the Manifest Destiny in the 1840s demonstrated that the call towards expansion was a crucial part of the national identity; it was instilled into the people that God had blessed them

    Read More

  • Was The Mexican-American War Justified?

    1199 Words  | 5 Pages

    The US did not not have solid reasons to do so besides their own greed, so the US hid behind the idea of Manifest Destiny and tried to justify their actions. John O’Sullivan was the New York City journalist who coined the term Manifest Destiny. He said, “Imbecile and distracted, Mexico never can exert any real government authority over such a country…’’ (O’Sullivan, 8). O’Sullivan and the US suggested that Mexico “needed” the US to come and take over, because otherwise Mexico was going to fall apart. Although this was somewhat true, the US did not try to help Mexico through this difficult time; instead, the US took advantage of Mexico’s weakness and tried to take over completely.

    Read More

  • James Monroe Accomplishments

    465 Words  | 2 Pages

    His three major ones were the Monroe Doctrine and his acquisition of Florida from Spain. With the Monroe Doctrine, James Monroe established that no European power would be allowed to interfere in the western hemisphere and any attempts to do so would be seen as a threat. This Doctrine established the U.S. foreign policy for many years and defined American interests in the world. With Britain backing Monroe with his policy, no European nation dared to enter that area. Monroe also established neutrality with Latin America.

    Read More

  • Positive Effects Of The Monroe Doctrine

    498 Words  | 2 Pages

    This policy had a lot of influences and affects. The Monroe Doctrine had a lot of positive effects on the United States and Britain. It basically helped shape America as it is today. The Monroe doctrine states "In the wars of the European powers in matters relating to themselves we have never taken any part, nor does it comport with our policy to do so.

    Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of The Monroe Doctrine

Open Document