The timeless classic Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare explores the subject of political power and the tension that develops between individual morality and political expediency. Two significant characters in the play are Brutus and Mark Antony, who hold opposing views on morality and leadership. The question is, which character is more noble, Brutus or Mark Antony? Because of his dedication to his principles, his selfless sacrifice, and his tragic demise, I think Brutus is more noble than Mark Antony. One of the main reasons Brutus is more noble than Mark Antony is his dedication to his principles. Brutus is a man with high ideals who is driven by a sense of duty to his country. He believes Caesar's ambition endangers the Roman Republic and joins the conspiracy to assassinate him. In Act 2, Scene 1, Brutus makes it clear that his actions are motivated by a sense of responsibility to the Roman people, not personal animosity toward Caesar. He says, "It must be by his death, and, for my part, I know no personal cause to spurn at him, but for the general." This quote demonstrates Brutus's selflessness and his willingness to put the good of the country above his personal interests. …show more content…
Brutus is a tragic hero who meets a tragic end as a result of his commitment to his principles. Even though he is aware that joining the conspiracy could lead to his demise, he does so because he believes it is the right thing to do. In Act 5, Scene 5, Brutus realizes that his actions have led to the Roman Republic's demise and that he is doomed to lose. As he prepares to commit suicide, he says, "Caesar, now be still. I killed not thee with half so good a will." This quote demonstrates that Brutus is aware that killing Caesar might not have been the best course of action for the republic's future and that he thinks his own death will tip the scales and put things back the way they
Brutus pairs the words describing Caesar’s accomplishments with those describing his own reactions. For example, he says that “As Caesar loved me, I weep for him,” “…was valiant, I honor him,” and “…was ambitious, I slew him,” which provides examples of his usage of pathos, ethos, and logos, respectively. Brutus continuously tells the crowd that he loves Caesar, but loves Rome more, and this is his main argument supporting the assassination. He also wants to enforce his belief that he and the conspirators killed him because they believed his ambition would lead to danger. Because he mainly relied on the use of logic throughout his speech, Brutus’s appeal to the public is not very
Brutus realized that eventually Caesar would give in to the people and his pride and accept the crown. It was because of this that Brutus knew that he would have to eliminate Caesar. He took no pleasure in the idea of Caesar’s death, but recognized the necessity of it. In his statement, he says he has no personal reason to “spurn” or despise Caesar but that “for the general” or for his nation he must be a part of the plot to kill Caesar. By rejecting his own personal feelings for his friend Caesar and instead acting on behalf of the Roman Republic because of a sense of civic duty he embodies the concepts and core foundations of a civic humanist
Was Brutus Noble? In Shakespeare 's’ The Tragedy Of Julius Caesar, one of the main characters, Marcus Brutus, is found dead by the noble Mark Antony, and is called “The Noblest Roman Of Them All” (Julius Caesar Act 5, scene 5, 68–72). Antony 's’ statement is a true one for many reasons. The first reason would be that Brutus was a man who valued his friendships over all else.
he had to choose between his friendship with caesar and his public responsibility to prevent caesar's alleged ambition of undermining the roman republic. cassius has convinced brutus that caesar plan to instill himself as monarch. a monarchy would rob the romans of the long held liberties. brutus' character is summed us in marc antony's speech in the play. "this was the noblest of them all.
Brutus knows that an ambitious young man like Caesar will sometimes use humility to advance himself, but once he reaches the top, he turns his back on the people that helped him get where he is. Therefore Brutus knows that he must kill
He is convinced by the conspirators that Caesar is a threat to the Republic, and he ultimately decides to join them in their plot to assassinate Caesar. Brutus justifies his betrayal by stating that he is not killing Caesar out of personal ambition but out of a desire to protect the Roman Republic. However, his decision to join the conspirators ultimately leads to Caesar's death and the downfall of the Roman
In his soliloquy he says “I know no cause to spurn at him, but for the general”. This means that although Brutus is dear friends with Caesar he believes it is for the good
Near the beginning of act II, Brutus has a soliloquy in which he is trying to decide whether joining the conspiracy is the right thing to do. He discusses reasons for why killing Caesar may be appropriate for the current situation of him being crowned king. Brutus also reveals his thoughts about some of Caesar’s behavior and what could happen (based on human nature) if he is given power. In the end, he decides to join with the conspiracy and kill Caesar.
Brutus believes that Caesar will do more harm than good to the people, and reap benefits for himself. Brutus has already said this, but had said it in his own words, (II, i, 12-14). He has no clue if Caesar will use his power for the good and betterment for the people, or use it for his own needs and other
Before Brutus was going to kill himself, he gave a speech to his men. “Countrymen, my heart doth joy that yet in all my life I found no man but he was true to me. I shall glory by losing this day” (Shakespeare 88). Just moments before killing himself, Brutus speaks about the unwavering loyalty his men have shown him every day. He tells his countrymen that their loyalty brings him more joy than anyone will feel winning the battle.
“Et tu, Brute?” Caesar uttered his last words as he witnesses Brutus stab him, “Then fall Caesar!” Brutus was that of the most trusted of Caesar. He was persuaded into political extremism which pushed him to conspire with envious senators and ultimately, participate in the brutal assassination of Caesar, who was ruthlessly stabbed 33 times, so he could become active ruler in Rome in the works of William Shakespeare derived from the play Julius Caesar. With what is being claimed, Brutus couldn’t possibly have been a honest man but a traitor.
Brutus in the end starts to say “Why then, lead on.—O, that a man might know/ The end of this day’s business ere it come!” letting someone be a bigger person and have them lead instead of himself lead (5.3.33-34). Because he didn’t want to deal with Antony, Brutus killed himself. In the book, Julius Caesar Brutus is easily
Once reality is put into perspective, Brutus comes to the conclusion, “Farewell, good Strato. / Caesar, now be still. / I killed not thee with half so good a will” (V.v. 55-58). Following all the events that took course throughout the timeline, Brutus comes to terms that the only effort he can make to remotely make up for what he did is to take his own life, similarly to how he took Caesar’s. Many believe that a dignitary person would never let his weakness overpower his strong suits, meaning that Brutus is not worthy of leadership.
In the play Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, Brutus has a great love for his city, Rome, like no other man. He wants great things for his city and is not willing to let anyone lead Rome into misfortune. With this intention, when Julius Caesar becomes king, Brutus is not pleased. He believes Rome will suffer under the commands of Caesar. Therefore, without consideration of the possible consequences, his ambitions and desires for the good of Rome drives him to take the life of his own best friend.
He has to decide if his loyalty belongs to his friend or to his country. In the end, Brutus chooses to side with the conspirators and assassinate Caesar for the benefit of Rome. This poor decision ultimately leads to much suffering and eventually his inevitable demise. In summary, Brutus fulfills yet another prerequisite required of a tragic hero by making a misjudgment that results in a harsh fate.